HomeMirror
Hardware
smart mirror display
SHOW HN2015
How HN took it
23 positive, 64 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 8 critical, out of 97 comments about the project. Thread score +0.20.
Idea: 13 for, 2 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 3 againstDesign: 1 for, 1 againstDocs: 1 for, 1 againstPricing: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Awesome idea that blends software into the physical environment
From 1 comment
What an absolutely awesome idea. I love things like this that just blend software and information into the physical environment seamlessly. I see stuff like this and just think,…
davnicwil on HN
Cheap and affordable compared to commercial versions
From 2 comments
This is way more affordable than the same thing I saw at Harrod's for like $10,000. Awesome project! Can't wait to try this.
mholt on HNNot sure if it's this article or not (wouldn't surprise me), but there's a number of "one way mirror" plastic/acrylic sheets on Amazon, with Prime shipping. But all of the…
adanto6840 on HN
Great idea and clever execution
From 3 comments
I do like this. It is clever. But when I did something similar for my family, which displayed everyone's chores for the day, and any events we had going on, I simply mounted a…
codingdave on HNYears ago I stayed in a hotel once that had mirrors like this by the elevators. They were displaying the current weather and day's forecast I believe. I've wanted one ever since!
jonknee on HNvery awesome!
g10r on HN
Objections
Removing the tablet for updates is inconvenient, adhesive mounting concerns
From 2 comments
I'm guessing this is based off [1] which uses a normal monitor and a Raspberry Pi. This one looks much quicker and simpler than [1], but what if you need to do anything to the…
servercobra on HNLove this idea, but removing the device (if you have to) is what rubs me the wrong way. Anyone have any idea on the implications of mounting the device, say, 3mm away from the…
joshmn on HN
Privacy concerns with a camera and microphone behind a mirror
From 3 comments
A few years ago it was really popular for home entertainment electronics like stereo systems and DVD players to use this trick to make the display appear to be "floating" on a…
userbinator on HNMight want to electrical-tape over the phone's front-facing camera, and maybe even excavate out its microphone. Just In Case.
resc1440 on HNThis would be rather creepy if we're talking about a bathroom mirror.
lukashed on HN
Little value beyond what a phone already does
From 2 comments
So everything your phone does already with a swipe of a finger? I might be underestimating how this might be important in your daily morning routine, but I can fairly well tell…
dzhiurgis on HNYes, your phone can do everything that this mirror can and more. Well, except work as a mirror. The entire point of this is that this is a household object that you need anyway,…
maratd on HN
Requests
Voice control
From 2 comments
Great idea! It's stunning how this sort of futuristic seeming technology is actually possible using $50 in consumer electronics! But passive display of information is only part…
andrepd on HNI wonder if you could also rig up a few microphones to enable touch controls. I remember reading an early Stephenson novel, where a stereo system was described as a blank black…
pavel_lishin on HN
Motion or face detection to turn display on
From 2 comments
It would be really cool to add facial recognition at like 0.5hz to the phone so that it only turns the screen on when you're looking at it. Or alternatively customize the content…
natebleker on HNMaybe add a motion sensor to it?
artmageddon on HN
Touch control through the glass
From 2 comments
Does the tablet's touchscreen work through the mirror, or is this read-only? It's still really cool either way.
alwaysdoit on HNIt depends on the thickness of the two way mirror, but you may be able to get touch by removing the protective glass from the android tablet so that the digitizer is in direct…
vkjv on HN
Questions
Can the touchscreen work through the mirror?
From 1 comment
Does the tablet's touchscreen work through the mirror, or is this read-only? It's still really cool either way.
alwaysdoit on HN
Does a camera work behind the two-way mirror for face recognition?
From 2 comments
Does the device's camera work from behind the one-way-mirror? Specifically, does the device camera work well enough from behind the one-way-mirror to do accurate face…
lazaroclapp on HNAs I understand it, one-way mirrors let light pass in both directions. To be used as a "one-way" mirror it relies on the light differential between the two sides. Namely, it will…
lazaroclapp on HN
Do you need a true two-way mirror or can other reflective film work?
From 2 comments
I wish this went into a bit more detail about working with the mirror itself. Do you actually need a 2-way mirror? Or can you simply use something with that coating on one side?
knowaveragejoe on HNCan the "two way mirror" be created with "reflective window tint" (insulfilm in Brazil) glued onto a transparent acrylic sheet?
swah on HN
Alternatives named
Raspberry Pi magic mirror project
From 1 comment
I'm guessing this is based off [1] which uses a normal monitor and a Raspberry Pi. This one looks much quicker and simpler than [1], but what if you need to do anything to the…
servercobra on HN
Jasper voice assistant
From 1 comment
You may also be interested in Jasper: http://jasperproject.github.io/documentation/ So you can do voice activated mirrors.
phkahler on HN
AirDroid for remote tablet control
From 1 comment
Or use something like AirDroid[0] (to interact with the tablet) [0] https://www.airdroid.com/
michaelmior on HN