NotCRUD
Consumer and social
community forum
SHOW HN2015
70points
35comments
#393of 2,565 in 2015
Top 16%of 2015 by points
How HN took it
MixedNo clear lean
4 positive, 5 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 6 critical, out of 19 comments about the project. Thread score -0.03.
Idea: 2 for, 3 againstDesign: 1 for, 1 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 1 againstDocs: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Design looks good and is cool
From 2 comments
Like it! I wanted to read the footer of the page (to see what this is powered by) but scrolling down loads more content. (Pressing Esc+Page down simultaneously let me see it).
general_failure on HNLooks good, I don't get why you called it !CRUD however.
dutchbrit on HN
Useful resource for Indian developers
From 1 comment
It is extensively desi and useful. Coders of Indian SaaS companies are bookmarking it.
rajcharaborti on HN
Objections
Layout is busier than HN's simple design
From 3 comments
Cool idea, but the best part of HN (aside from the content) is how simple the layout and design is. Yours is not complex nor does it perform badly, but I don't get the same…
sotojuan on HNNice work...a little busy for my tastes but that could be a cultural thing :) An excellent showcase of your skills I think.
cubano on HNI remember reading about paraschopra and Wingify on HackerStreet India - an India-centric HN rip-off that didn't work out though paraschopra was pretty active in the early days.…
adarsh_y on HN
Post titles are truncated
From 2 comments
If you don't mind sharing the details, What is the tech stack? Also most of headlines are trimmed off. I have to click on the link just to know what this post is about. Longer…
YogeeKnows on HNI'm not able to see the full title of the posts (13" MBP Retina). It is cut off half-way. As a front-page for a HN-style site, that's a serious usability bug that you want to…
smhx on HN
Showing online users is a privacy concern
From 1 comment
The online users part of the site is pretty concerning, I wonder if they intend to keep it there? I wouldn’t want to sign up to a site that broadcasts when I am online…
Tinyyy on HN
The CRUD explanation and Indian-focus framing are criticized
From 2 comments
> showcase the best of Indian creativity and ingenuity in product development. I genuinely don't understand above. You want to showcase the "best creativity" by showing that you…
linuxkerneldev on HNThat is quite flawed. and quite honestly one of the dumbest things I have ever read here. You also come across as quite arrogant or entitled when you say that all CRUD…
thrownear on HN
Requests
Show full post titles
From 2 comments
If you don't mind sharing the details, What is the tech stack? Also most of headlines are trimmed off. I have to click on the link just to know what this post is about. Longer…
YogeeKnows on HNI'm not able to see the full title of the posts (13" MBP Retina). It is cut off half-way. As a front-page for a HN-style site, that's a serious usability bug that you want to…
smhx on HN
Remove infinite scrolling and the footer is unreachable
From 2 comments
You may want to rethink the presence of that unreachable footer, given the contemporary presence of infinite scrolling...
trumbitta2 on HNCool idea, but the best part of HN (aside from the content) is how simple the layout and design is. Yours is not complex nor does it perform badly, but I don't get the same…
sotojuan on HN
Add guidelines or FAQs
From 1 comment
Calling it Hacker News of India, but I'm not able to find any Guildlines or FAQs on your site.
dhruvsachde on HN
Threaded replies
From 1 comment
Thanks for the feedback on design. We used NodeBB and threaded replies is something on our agenda. HN design works really well right now because the new content posted is much…
paraschopra on HN
Questions
What is the tech stack?
From 1 comment
If you don't mind sharing the details, What is the tech stack? Also most of headlines are trimmed off. I have to click on the link just to know what this post is about. Longer…
YogeeKnows on HN
Why is it called NotCRUD?
From 2 comments
Looks good, I don't get why you called it !CRUD however.
dutchbrit on HNFrom http://thenextweb.com/in/2015/09/03/notcrud-is-a-hacker-news-inspired-community-for-developers-in-india/ PC: “CRUD refers to basic database functions — create, read, update…
saaadhu on HN
Alternatives named
HackerStreet India
From 3 comments
I remember reading about paraschopra and Wingify on HackerStreet India - an India-centric HN rip-off that didn't work out though paraschopra was pretty active in the early days.…
adarsh_y on HNI thought http://hackerstreet.in/ was kinda already Hackernews for Indian audience?
gnufied on HNhackerstreet has lost it's relevance and it's not really maintained anymore. I plan to shut it down sometime soon.
prateekdayal on HN