Mastodon
Infrastructure
federated social server
SHOW HN2017
How HN took it
8 positive, 23 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 8 critical, out of 39 comments about the project. Thread score +0.04.
Idea: 5 for, 1 againstDesign: 2 for, 3 againstExecution: 0 for, 3 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Mastodon is a much better execution of the idea than GNU social
From 1 comment
If you try GNU social and Mastodon I believe with a high confidence that you'll find that Mastodon is a much better execution of the idea. So yeah my goal is for this to be the…
daveid on HN
Feels like a Twitter-style site that works as expected
From 1 comment
Looks pretty good from what I've seen. Set up an account for my site, posted a few messages to test how it works and found that everything seems pretty much as I'd expect from a…
CM30 on HN
Private feature liked
From 1 comment
I like this... especially the private feature!!!!
macawfish on HN
Objections
Name is awkward and may not go mainstream
From 1 comment
But that name... "Can you mastodon me?" Ugh. I don't see this going mainstream with a name like this. I don't think anyone at NBC is ever going to say, "let's see what's trending…
JustSomeNobody on HN
Public timeline has offensive content and no way to hide it
From 1 comment
I signed up and tried it out. The "Public" thing on the right side apparently can't be shut off. About every third toot has four-letter words. Racism, sexually inappropriate…
bachmeier on HN
Does not federate well with GNU social codebase, some content disappears
From 2 comments
This doesn't play nice federating with the GNU Social codebase. Things that should travel across simply disappears. It needs more work.
smkellat on HNI would ping you except that your server doesn't talk to Quitter.se while the rest of the GNU Social federation does so just fine. I'm remote-subscribed to people there yet they…
smkellat on HN
Requests
Browse without registering
From 2 comments
I might be bit dense, but can you browse this thing somehow without first registering?
zokier on HNforgot? people have been asking you for this feature for ages.
xj9 on HN
Cross-post from Twitter
From 1 comment
Is there some easy way for me to automatically cross-post my twitter posts to Mastodon?
udfalkso on HN
Public timeline feed
From 1 comment
You can browse individual accounts, e.g.: https://mastodon.social/users/Gargron https://mastodon.social/users/Triplefox But there isn't a feed of the public timeline which would…
buzzybee on HN
Questions
How to discover users across instances
From 2 comments
"GNU social" - good, I like that protocol suite... But how do I discover fellow users to fill my subscription list across different sites ? Can I search across the whole networks…
liotier on HNDiscovery: If someone from your instance follows someone remotely, that account is in the instance's database, and can be searched (we have account search). Furthermore you'll…
daveid on HN
How to avoid spam from federated instances
How many active users
From 2 comments
How many active users ? Like, accessing the platform once a week or more ?
Gys on HNI don't do any real tracking except for login times, so here is the best data i can offer (for mastodon.social exclusively, other Mastodon and GNU social instances are obviously…
daveid on HN
Alternatives named
GNU social
From 2 comments
Looks pretty good from what I've seen. Set up an account for my site, posted a few messages to test how it works and found that everything seems pretty much as I'd expect from a…
CM30 on HN>"GNU Social seems to be catching on a fair bit nowadays, and that feels a lot like this software too." The GitHub page describes Mastodon as "An alternative implementation of…
ZenoArrow on HN
Twitter
From 1 comment
Is there some easy way for me to automatically cross-post my twitter posts to Mastodon?
udfalkso on HN
Known
From 1 comment
You might want to consider using Known ( https://withknown.com/ ) or backing http://micro.blog/ if you want good, cross-network cross-posting.
pmlnr on HN
micro.blog
From 1 comment
You might want to consider using Known ( https://withknown.com/ ) or backing http://micro.blog/ if you want good, cross-network cross-posting.
pmlnr on HN
pump.io
From 1 comment
Can you elaborate or provide sources? AFAIK GNU social's current codebase is a merge [1] between StatusNet and Free Social, with StatusNet previously known as Laconica [2] and…
niftich on HN