Pipes
Dev tools
visual programming
SHOW HN2017
How HN took it
15 positive, 20 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 11 critical, out of 50 comments about the project. Thread score +0.08.
Idea: 9 for, 2 againstDesign: 4 for, 4 againstPerformance: 0 for, 3 againstPrivacy: 1 for, 0 againstExecution: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Nostalgia for Yahoo Pipes and welcome revival of the tool
From 3 comments
I really loved Yahoo Pipes - Was ahead of its time if you ask me..Built some very cool automations on top of this. Basically was IFTTT and Zapier well before them.
scottmcleod on HNPipes was a handy tool, hope this project keeps up!
j45 on HNI don't think you remember how the yahoo pipes worked. It was a brilliant mix of graphs for flow control, premade boxes for all common data manipulation and scripting for that…
LoSboccacc on HN
Objections
Node-based visual wiring scales poorly to large programs
From 2 comments
I've some experience in visual programming languages (both professional and in my studies) and I advise against the graph-form where you connect nodes and edges. This does not…
zeptomu on HNIMO, the reason the wiring model doesn't scale up is that most don't provide a way to create submodules (compounds?). I expect that decomposing a problem into a chain of smaller…
jldugger on HN
Hard to see the output block and link pipeline to output
From 2 comments
Nice. It's not very clear that you need to link the pipeline to the right-hand side. (I can't remember if you had to do that on Yahoo, it's been so long!). It's particularly a…
insomniacity on HNI used to use yahoo pipes for a few twitter bots I had. There was an rss to twitter webapp that I hooked up and it was fully automated for years before it stopped working. I…
anonfunction on HN
Site was unreachable or slow when first posted
From 2 comments
Dead (could not connect to server)
rjeli on HNPlease try again. It should be up (works for me and http://downforeveryoneorjustme.com/www.pipes.digital supports that). Though I forgot scaling up the droplet it is running on…
onli on HN
Requests
Starter example pipes and code examples
From 2 comments
would like to suggest a couple of "starter pipes" - samples to more easily illustrate some possibilities.
mgkimsal on HNcouple of code examples would be nice
yownie on HN
Support for scraping with CSS selectors or XPath
From 2 comments
Do you plan on supporting scraping content via css selectors/xpath/regex?
Toast_ on HNI added a block to download a page (instead of a feed), another block for extracting content via css selector or xpath, and a feed builder block to later combine those (but the…
onli on HN
JSON processing like jq
From 1 comment
Neat. Any chance of adding JSON processing where you can pick a key (ala `jq`[0]) and then combine it with RSS or other JSON or what have you? [0] https://stedolan.github.io/jq/
hehheh on HN
Questions
How does it compare to Zapier and IFTTT?
From 1 comment
This is cool, but I feel like Zapier, IFTTT and their open source equivalents have moved far past Yahoo Pipes. How do you see this stacking up?
michaelbuckbee on HN
Does it support sub-pipe inputs and modules?
From 2 comments
IMO, the reason the wiring model doesn't scale up is that most don't provide a way to create submodules (compounds?). I expect that decomposing a problem into a chain of smaller…
jldugger on HNIt only had submodules in the sense that you could embed a pipe, but IIRC, they were always sources -- you couldn't pipe data into them. It had a notion of the 'output' block but…
jldugger on HN
Alternatives named
Node-RED
From 2 comments
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned Node-RED yet: http://nodered.org/ Node.js-based with a Pipes-like visual wiring interface. It's quite popular with the Raspberry Pi and Arduino…
beardicus on HNI'd love something like this that I can run locally. From looking at the comments, it looks like Node-RED and NoFlo are two possibilities. I was intrigued by Yahoo Pipes a while…
Mister_Snuggles on HN
NoFlo
From 1 comment
Interesting, have to take a proper look tomorrow. We've done similar things with NoFlo (https://noflojs.org)
bergie on HN
Zapier
From 1 comment
This is cool, but I feel like Zapier, IFTTT and their open source equivalents have moved far past Yahoo Pipes. How do you see this stacking up?
michaelbuckbee on HN
IFTTT
From 1 comment
This is cool, but I feel like Zapier, IFTTT and their open source equivalents have moved far past Yahoo Pipes. How do you see this stacking up?
michaelbuckbee on HN
Apache NiFi
From 1 comment
Its interesting and I do applaud your work, but I'll probably just stick to Apache Nifi with its flexibility.
technologia on HN
KNIME and RapidMiner
From 1 comment
Checkout Rapidminer and Knime for great examples of box'n'arrows applied to machine learning pipelines. I've used Rapidminer a fair bit and they really have a great model…
bayonetz on HN