SimulDocs
Dev tools
version control
SHOW HN2017
How HN took it
18 positive, 22 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 14 critical, out of 58 comments about the project. Thread score +0.12.
Idea: 15 for, 10 againstPrivacy: 1 for, 2 againstPricing: 1 for, 1 againstExecution: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Useful idea that fills a real need for versioning Word documents
From 4 comments
Many others have said it already, but I'll say it again: 1. You have a fantastic product 2. Many potential users won't accept to have their documents stored "in the cloud" (even…
bambax on HNFinally someone is doing this! I've been toying with the idea myself but haven't been able to dedicate time to it, mostly I was deterred by the MS Word format mess. I'm sure it…
rsp1984 on HNI think if you can get people to use this and try it, you're going to make a ton of cash. This has been needed for years and doing it within Word sounds to me like the absolute…
thebiglebrewski on HNI think this is a good product, once worked in strategy as an intern at a bank and we basically used manual versioning where we would version using date and time or even content,…
forkLding on HN
Could be valuable for compliance-heavy fields like banking, legal and engineering
From 3 comments
I could recommend this for something like bank compliance. We're stuck with Word and have a largely non-technical staff, but could dramatically improve our performance if our…
ellius on HNSignificant. Most engineering firms (web dev << the development world) have a need for proper documentation, and LibreOffice generally won't cut it either.
TickleSteve on HNIf you had a version that companies could install on a private internal network, you could easily charge between $100 and $1000 a month for this. I work in legal and compliance…
tmaly on HN
Objections
Cloud hosting of confidential documents is a barrier; wants on-premise or self-hosting
From 3 comments
This fills a niche I need but I can't use a service where I upload the documents to your server (unless you can show certification of at least ISO 27001). I would also be willing…
Beltiras on HNThis is very cool, and I wish we had something like this, but I don't see many law firms going for it. Most law firms (and I would guess all major ones) will not allow uploading…
nvlr on HNGood idea in general, but with one major flaw: no self-hosting option. I can't imagine lawyers will be queuing up to host their sensitive legal documents on someone else's server.
ZenoArrow on HN
Built-in Word Track Changes and SharePoint versioning may already be enough
From 3 comments
This is interesting, but what's wrong with "Track Changes"? (a feature Word had for at least 10+ years now). I believe for most people that is more than enough for version…
gigelu on HNTHIS is how Sharepoint should have worked from day 1. But I guess Microsoft thinks normal office workers won't get version history in their mind.
therealmarv on HNUnfortunately can't check it out because I get "We are checking what's changed in this version. Won't be long..." for any test docx I upload / blank docx. Maybe server…
moontear on HN
Git references may confuse non-technical target users
From 2 comments
The group of people who still do their day-to-day by passing around Word docs via email or LAN likely does not intersect well with the people who fully understand (or have much…
pmarreck on HNFrom the article ``` There is a lot of overlap here with the authoring process of a Word document. You don’t necessarily want the real-time coauthoring experience offered by…
Atheb on HN
Requests
Self-hosting or on-premise installation option
From 2 comments
If you had a version that companies could install on a private internal network, you could easily charge between $100 and $1000 a month for this. I work in legal and compliance…
tmaly on HNGood idea in general, but with one major flaw: no self-hosting option. I can't imagine lawyers will be queuing up to host their sensitive legal documents on someone else's server.
ZenoArrow on HN
Compare against Track Changes and SharePoint versioning in marketing
From 2 comments
Cool! Here's my unsolicited opinion: you preemptively answer "why wouldn't I just use git?" but I think "why is this better than track changes?" is the question prospective users…
emodendroket on HNUnfortunately can't check it out because I get "We are checking what's changed in this version. Won't be long..." for any test docx I upload / blank docx. Maybe server…
moontear on HN
Ability to delete documents
From 1 comment
Is there any way to delete documents? I uploaded a trash document just to try it out, but now I can never delete it - only "archive it" which is bugging the OCD side of me
ythn on HN
Questions
How does it handle complex formatting changes?
From 1 comment
Unfortunately can't check it out because I get "We are checking what's changed in this version. Won't be long..." for any test docx I upload / blank docx. Maybe server…
moontear on HN
Why does installation need admin rights?
From 1 comment
Why do you need admin rights to install?
fleurdelotus on HN
Alternatives named
Google Docs
From 2 comments
So Google Docs? It seems close enough. What's the main advantage over Google Docs?
mtgx on HNWord is tons more powerful than Google Docs, has add-ins, way more formatting and styling. In my mind, Google Doc is not a direct competitor to Word when it comes to professional…
Khao on HN
SharePoint versioning
From 2 comments
Hey OP, this looks like an awesome tool, good job! Just a quick question, would the primary alternative to your product be Microsoft Sharepoint? If so, how would you market your…
yazan94 on HNTHIS is how Sharepoint should have worked from day 1. But I guess Microsoft thinks normal office workers won't get version history in their mind.
therealmarv on HN
Git with pandoc conversion to markdown
From 1 comment
I've used git for word docs for years now. Using pandoc to convert them to markdown allows sensible diffs to be displayed as well. Works great for redlining.
koolba on HN
Draftable compare tool
From 1 comment
If all you need is to diff documents (Word, Excel, PPT, or arbitrary PDFs) then I can't recommend https://draftable.com/compare enough. It's an amazing tool. Granted, you need to…
btown on HN