Trennd
Data
search trend discovery
SHOW HN2019
How HN took it
18 positive, 42 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 14 critical, out of 78 comments about the project. Thread score +0.07.
Idea: 11 for, 2 againstExecution: 0 for, 4 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 3 againstDesign: 1 for, 2 againstPerformance: 0 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Useful, interesting concept
From 3 comments
I don’t have much feedback, except to say I think this is a really good, useful concept.
charlesism on HNThis is really cool.
akl_bh on HNGreat stuff. Thanks
Havoc on HN
Useful for e-commerce and marketers catching trends early
From 1 comment
I'm a moderator of one of the bigger Facebook advertising groups that exist. This caught my eye instantly as the e-commerce and affiliate crowd are going to be all over it. They…
jsonne on HN
Objections
Results skew heavily toward tech, not true discovery
From 3 comments
These results aren't filtered in some way? I find it suspicious that almost all of the top ~100 results are tech related.
ashelmire on HNVery cool, but this is essentially not "discovery". There is a heavy skew toward tech - but niche tech (Notion for example) specifically. It would be cool to get a broader, less…
beardedman on HNThe examples on the front page looks surprisingly good, which makes me suspect they were hand-picked. Kind of beats the purpose of the app if I'm just shown trends the author and…
tw1010 on HN
Trends shown are only existing Google Trends data, not early signals
From 1 comment
not sure i agree so much because its not showing things that are just starting to trend, which is where the real money is at... being in front of the ball rather then…
mtnGoat on HN
Signing up requests excessive Twitter permissions
From 1 comment
Very cool! As a front-end dev it's interesting (but I guess also not surprising) to see React and Vue with very steep curves. I wanted to try adding Svelte, so I signed up by…
dceddia on HN
Server went down under Hacker News traffic
From 2 comments
Cool idea, but all charts are empty. Hugged by Hacker News?
kmorris1077 on HNWeb server down? Anyone else getting it to load?
throw03172019 on HN
Requests
Filter trends by location or country
From 2 comments
Hi Josh - it would be incredible to have this filtered by location, and I think you can get that from Google Trends.
taneem on HNWhat could be a really neat addition is having trends sorted by countries
maxencecornet on HN
Show downward trends and shorter time windows like 30 days
From 2 comments
I'd also like to see downward trends, not just growing trend. From the last page or two, I see some downward trend, like "blog", "facebook", and "gmail". I don't know if it means…
otterpro on HNFor sure. So shorter term. They're going to want to move faster than 3 months. Maybe like a past 30 day trend if possible? I would say also if there's a way you could dig into…
jsonne on HN
More specific categories such as programming languages or sports players
From 2 comments
Hey Josh, very interesting concept. Thanks for building it! I tried to use the "technology" category, but the results are not what I expected. Perhaps it would be more useful if…
simonebrunozzi on HNThis is awesome. I'd love to have the ability to view topics based on category. IE. see the biggest trends in entertainment or the biggest trends in sports players, or the…
AznHisoka on HN
API or CSV access to the data
From 2 comments
Is there a plan to sell the data as an API? I am currently working with a client who is exploring the options for building out a similar system.
suvelx on HNSelling the data as an API is definitely a potential. I was originally thinking to allow CSV downloads of the data. Would an API be more useful for your client's use case?
jhow15 on HN
Short explanations for keywords and axis units
From 2 comments
Hi, it would be nice if the keywords had short explanations. I had to find out what an affinity designer and an enneagram was. Bubble tea was also quite new.
nurettin on HNLooks good, but I miss units on the axis. On mobile, it's missing from the start page. The units for the y-axis on the detail view is missing (as far as I can see).
pengstrom on HN
Questions
How keywords are chosen and how trends are calculated
From 4 comments
You said you are monitoring interesting keywords & topics but how do you know which keywords & topics to monitor? Also, if you are choosing the keywords then wouldn't the data be…
deadcoder0904 on HNHi Josh, Very interesting stuff. Can I ask what is the math behind defining the trend? How did you calculate the most trendy words, etc? I'm working on something similar for a…
yuy910616 on HNWhat is your Algo for calculating Trends? I mean how do you say that something is trending? It is most popular? Emerging? Z-score?
apexkid on HNThat's very neat and interesting; I guess the two questions are - how do you generate keywords to search for ? - how do you filter out noise (or perhaps you don't filter it) ?
donmatito on HN
Is the project open source
From 1 comment
Very cool! Thank you for sharing -- and for creating it! Have you considered taking a step further in the "open" direction and making it OSS?
chrisweekly on HN
Alternatives named
Glimpse newsletter
From 1 comment
This is similar in some ways to https://meetglimpse.com/ The key value-add, in my mind, from that product, besides the trend, is the editorial content they include in the email.…
bluepeter on HN
Google Trends
From 2 comments
Awesome I enjoyed making some trend charts, and the results are fun (i.e I added DevOps, Erlang, Elixir). I think there is a risk it could conceal too many errors and biases for…
tasssko on HNWhere's the data coming from? I assume the trends are coming from Google Trends but how are topics found?
driverdan on HN
Google AdWords keyword tools
From 1 comment
Awesome I enjoyed making some trend charts, and the results are fun (i.e I added DevOps, Erlang, Elixir). I think there is a risk it could conceal too many errors and biases for…
tasssko on HN