Notado
Productivity
bookmarking
SHOW HN2020
96points
29comments
#671of 3,028 in 2020
Top 23%of 2020 by points
How HN took it
MixedNo clear lean
2 positive, 5 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 5 critical, out of 14 comments about the project. Thread score -0.17.
Execution: 0 for, 4 againstIdea: 2 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Polished, slick front page and out-of-the-box integrations
From 2 comments
No self-hosting capabilities unfortunately make this a non-starter for me, but I do really appreciate how slick your front page is and all the integrations you're offering out of…
kemonocode on HNGreat frontpage and app. I love the integrations and automation section which shows great potential. Few critics and requests: * Please make the signup box more…
conqrr on HN
Login without passwords
From 1 comment
Nice idea. Love that it works without passwords.
amadeuspagel on HN
Objections
No self-hosting option
From 2 comments
No self-hosting capabilities unfortunately make this a non-starter for me, but I do really appreciate how slick your front page is and all the integrations you're offering out of…
kemonocode on HNThis looks exactly like something I’ve been looking for. Would you ever consider making it available for self hosting ala BitWarden for a license fee? I’d be more than happy to…
ceocoder on HN
Signup box not prominent enough
From 1 comment
Great frontpage and app. I love the integrations and automation section which shows great potential. Few critics and requests: * Please make the signup box more…
conqrr on HN
Magic login links expire quickly and email validation had bugs
From 2 comments
Your email input box might need some tweaks. I entered my email and had a space after it ( i actually used a text expander to quickly input it resulting in the extra space), it…
shacrw on HNTrying to sign up. I click the "Log in to Notado" email link and get a "401: Unauthorized The request requires user authentication." error. Am I doing something wrong?
take_a_breath on HN
Risk the service disappears
From 1 comment
The biggest risk for bookmark app nowadays is that you don't know when it's going to disappear.
hajimuz on HN
Requests
Self-hosting option, possibly paid license
From 2 comments
This looks exactly like something I’ve been looking for. Would you ever consider making it available for self hosting ala BitWarden for a license fee? I’d be more than happy to…
ceocoder on HNseconding the request for a self hosting option, as well as the payment of a licensing fee (which I'd be happy to pay, as this is also something I've been looking for)
wetwiper on HN
Push to Kindle integration
From 1 comment
Great frontpage and app. I love the integrations and automation section which shows great potential. Few critics and requests: * Please make the signup box more…
conqrr on HN
Support for book highlights and Readwise sync
From 1 comment
I use readwise.io as something similar. Does this support adding quotations from books? I guess you could reference an ISBN database as a hack for the primary key.
philips on HN
Questions
Does it support adding quotes from books?
From 1 comment
I use readwise.io as something similar. Does this support adding quotations from books? I guess you could reference an ISBN database as a hack for the primary key.
philips on HN
Why does login link return 401?
From 1 comment
Trying to sign up. I click the "Log in to Notado" email link and get a "401: Unauthorized The request requires user authentication." error. Am I doing something wrong?
take_a_breath on HN
Alternatives named
Readwise
From 1 comment
I use readwise.io as something similar. Does this support adding quotations from books? I guess you could reference an ISBN database as a hack for the primary key.
philips on HN
Bitwarden (as a self-hosting model reference)
From 1 comment
This looks exactly like something I’ve been looking for. Would you ever consider making it available for self hosting ala BitWarden for a license fee? I’d be more than happy to…
ceocoder on HN
Instapaper
From 1 comment
It doesn't support adding highlights from books; I primarily listen to audiobooks these days so it wasn't a feature that made the cut when I was defining the scope for Notado.…
bsnnkv on HN