Fast Flood
Games
browser puzzle game
SHOW HN2022
How HN took it
27 positive, 30 neutral or asking, 10 mixed, 25 critical, out of 92 comments about the project. Thread score +0.00.
Design: 3 for, 11 againstIdea: 9 for, 4 againstExecution: 0 for, 9 againstDocs: 1 for, 1 againstPerformance: 1 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Fun and addictive, with a Wordle-like feel
From 3 comments
This is fun and seems to replicate more closely the things I enjoyed about Wordle than other attempts. Well done! Fast Flood No.3 → ⌛ → 29 seconds ▶ → 15 moves → 1 try
JadoJodo on HNThis is incredibly addicting
taterbase on HNFast Flood No.3 → ⌛ → 20 seconds ▶ → 18 moves → 2 tries Super fun!!!!
runekaagaard on HN
Clean, simple mechanics that are easy to learn
From 2 comments
I was not expecting much, but that’s pretty good! It’s Tetris-simple, but still challenging give the time limit. Great job!
garren on HNTook a minute to figure out, but thought it was fun. Thanks for sharing!
rajangdavis on HN
Objections
Timer is stressful and cuts players off
From 4 comments
Fast Flood No.4 → ⌛ → 31 seconds ▶ → 18 moves → 1 try Quite fun! Nicely made. My (hopefully constructive) feedback: - Bug: I refreshed the page on my first try and it told me to…
DecoPerson on HNI like knowing the time but I don't like being cut off by it. Just let it count up. Same with the moves. You can say what "par" is to make a goal to achieve, but let people take…
jedberg on HNtoo stressful Fast Flood No.3 → ⌛ → 59 seconds ▶ → 18 moves → 1 try
kowlo on HNFast Flood No.3 → ⌛ → 57 seconds ▶ → 17 moves → 1 try Nice concept! - I had to considerately speed up my game after realising I was running out of time - The frenetic pace is not…
jokethrowaway on HN
Once-a-day lock-out after refresh or going back to instructions
From 4 comments
Why do I have to "come back tomorrow" to play a game more than once? What a weird anti-user feature. Have to delete cookies to play a game! What next, be allowed to play one game…
lloydatkinson on HNI get that you're following the "once a day" wordle model, but you're going to lose a lot of people who go in blindly (like me), don't understand the game, and then discover…
madrox on HNI didn't complete the first game and reloaded the page and now I can't play until tomorrow. In this case I think the imposed limit is kinda "artificial" and would work better…
dagi3d on HNI went back to the instruction page realizing I really needed to understand it before playing. Now it shows comeback tomorrow.
papa2034 on HN
Emojis don't render on older OS or browsers
From 4 comments
It looks like it uses "modern" emojis that aren't available on our OS.
slig on HNThey don't render in macOS 10.13 (the latest version I can install on my girlfriend's 2009 iMac) either. I've found that any time I'm using emojis for something substantial, I…
hombre_fatal on HNI'm using a recent Firefox on a stock Android on a Samsung 8. The game only shows brownish rectangles. I know the phone is considered antique by today's standards, but still...
xcambar on HNDoesn't work at all in Brave, all I see are rectangles.
Geste on HN
Instructions are unclear at first
From 3 comments
I get that you're following the "once a day" wordle model, but you're going to lose a lot of people who go in blindly (like me), don't understand the game, and then discover…
madrox on HNI skimmed the tutorial and just clicked around my first round, not rly sure what was going on until around the end of the round. Second round I understood the mechanics but ran…
jareklupinski on HNTook my a run to understand how to play. Thought I had to click on the titles to pick what colors I wanted. Got it the second go though!
bl4ckneon on HN
Requests
Remove or make the timer optional
From 3 comments
I like knowing the time but I don't like being cut off by it. Just let it count up. Same with the moves. You can say what "par" is to make a goal to achieve, but let people take…
jedberg on HNVery fun. I like the timer and move limit to add a bit more pressure, but agree with other commenters that it may not always be desirable. My suggestion is to have different…
seandavidfisher on HNI'm not exactly sure how it would change the gameplay, but I wonder what it would be like if the starting point wasn't always in a corner? Also - not a fan of the timer.
s1mon on HN
Keep game state and score after returning to the page
From 2 comments
I like the move limit- it's part of what gives Wordle and its associated games (have you tried Sedordle?) their charm. One thing I'd definitely like to see would be the ability…
jackson1442 on HNThis is fun, thanks! It seems like once I solve a puzzle if I don't copy my results I have no way of seeing them. I'm at a screen that says to come back tomorrow.
evandale on HN
Colour-blind mode as default or letters on tiles
From 3 comments
I tried it three times and failed, got frustrated, then opened it in a private window and turned on color blind mode and got it on the first try! I think color blind mode is way…
jedberg on HNI'd love a mode that adds some letters on the tiles, as I'm colorblind and have difficulty differentiating colors.
bobthebuilders on HNCool game mechanic, I haven't seen anything quite like it. I think you could remove the UI options at the bottom entirely. Instead have the user click on the adjacent squares…
codeyperson on HN
Larger board
From 1 comment
Can the board be made larger? I found the game was over too quickly and there was little scope for strategic thinking by looking ahead for channels with lots of branches.
billpg on HN
Shareable link in the share button
From 2 comments
Fun game! I'd suggest adding a link to the shareable clipboard score.
dbielik on HNSorry to add a third comment, but I'd love the 'share' button to include the game's url
serverlessmom on HN
Questions
Is there a better solving strategy?
From 2 comments
I enjoyed this game! My strategy was simple: Scan the boundaries of the area of cells stemming from the top-left corner cell which are of the same color, and attempt to determine…
g4zj on HNSeems like a fun game but I don't think it'll hit the worldle success because the dividide the middle and aim straigh for the diagonal strategy gets you a win pretty much every…
calculated on HN
Can it be published to app stores?
From 1 comment
Now what is the best way today to publish such JavaScript app in Google or Apple app stores?
ptrwis on HN
Alternatives named
Wordle
From 2 comments
Fast Flood No.4 → ⌛ → 31 seconds ▶ → 18 moves → 1 try Quite fun! Nicely made. My (hopefully constructive) feedback: - Bug: I refreshed the page on my first try and it told me to…
DecoPerson on HNIt's trying to copy the artificial scarcity of Wordle, which limits the amount of times you can play to encourage sharing the link.
umvi on HN
Assimilate (Flood-It port)
From 1 comment
Assimilate (Flood-It for Mac OS 9) was posted on HN recently; did that inspire you? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30176448
re on HN
Simon Tatham's Puzzles Flood
From 1 comment
Not really. I missed that post. I was looking for logic games and found Flood in Simon Tatham's puzzles collection: https://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/puzzles/
dylanjcastillo on HN