Emacs Configuration Generator
Dev tools
editor configuration generator
SHOW HN2022
Legend
Emacs Configuration Generator
Web tool that generates a starter Emacs configuration from answers to questionsAI
emacs.amodernist.comHow HN took it
19 positive, 29 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 5 critical, out of 57 comments about the project. Thread score +0.28.
Idea: 11 for, 3 againstExecution: 2 for, 2 againstDocs: 1 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Useful starter for newcomers and a good alternative to heavy distributions
From 3 comments
This looks like it solves a very real pain point for anyone getting started with Emacs, and likely many people who have been using Emacs for a long time sub-optimally. Could save…
jimbokun on HNI like it. I installed Doom Emacs a few weeks back but had to give it up. I personally don’t like to bring in a huge config set in the beginning. I like this idea and will try to…
larusso on HNThis is really cool - the generated config turned out shorter than just my .spacemacs config file which makes it feel accessible. I like it.
CraigJPerry on HN
Opinionated sensible defaults
From 2 comments
Neat. I like the fact that it is opinionated providing a decent setup to get things done. Here are some of the things i was confused about, or thought could be improved. 1. The…
rmnull on HNVery neat tool. Ive been getting more and more into using emacs. I like the options you provide like disabling the tool bar, line numbers etc. these are quality of life changes…
wara23arish on HN
Objections
Built-in Customize already provides this
From 2 comments
The customize interface built into Emacs already provides this. Though it supports customizing far more things, so it might be overwhelming. Maybe a new user customization group…
catern on HNI'm not getting why you wouldn't just use Emacs's customize to do the job?
cbsmith on HN
Generated config has bugs and missing pieces (splash screen, unused packages, LSP setup)
From 3 comments
Hello, I think you have a bug disabling the splash screen: https://git.sr.ht/~pkal/ecg/tree/master/item/ecg.lisp#L372 According to the internet (I don't use emacs) it's supposed…
ancientsofmumu on HNThis looks interesting but would be much better if it just went with use-package across the board. You also have not enabled many of the modes that you install which will be a…
WhatIsDukkha on HNI gave it a shot and several things were broken. It's a nice idea, but definitely needs more polishing.
r-zip on HN
Web interface is clunky with screenshots in EWW
From 1 comment
As there are currently no Javascript dependencies, it is possible to use the site using EWW: M-x eww https://emacs.amodernist.com/ RET. That being said, the screenshots get in…
daptaq on HN
Requests
Run from inside Emacs or generate an Elisp or org file
From 3 comments
Interesting, but you know what might even be better? If it could be done directly from emacs. E.g. if you start with a brand new emacs then you could paste a line into scratch,…
dmortin on HNArgh! Of course something cool like this gets shared on the day I'm super busy. Can't wait to mess with this. For extra nerd cred, output a .org file that can use babel to…
bloopernova on HNSomething like this built directly into emacs that launches when people run it for the first time with no config (and no file opened) would be great.
globular-toast on HN
Use use-package and evil-collection
From 2 comments
This looks interesting but would be much better if it just went with use-package across the board. You also have not enabled many of the modes that you install which will be a…
WhatIsDukkha on HNNeat tool. I tried generating a config similar to mine, and it was surprisingly close, although it looks quite different without use-package. Did you not add use-package because…
lvass on HN
Option to disable backup files
From 1 comment
Looks pretty good, I'll give it a spin soon as I'm trying to migrate from Doom to a vanilla config. One thing's that seems to be missing is that option to disable those pesky…
sph on HN
Doom-style mnemonic keybindings
From 1 comment
this is definitely a useful tool, thank you for putting the work into it! from the evil camp, it works be really useful if it also included an option to generate doom/spacemacs…
karmajunkie on HN
Questions
Why not use built-in Customize
From 1 comment
I'm not getting why you wouldn't just use Emacs's customize to do the job?
cbsmith on HN
Why LSP setup asks for language modes separately
From 1 comment
Quick question; I was a little confused by the fact that after asking for LSP support, and answering affirmatively, I went through a list of programming language modes to…
jonnycomputer on HN
Alternatives named
Built-in Customize and package manager
From 2 comments
The Emacs built-in “Customize” tool is very close to that, and there’s also the built-in package manager. I guess this kind of generator could be implemented inside Emacs itself…
hcarvalhoalves on HNThe customize interface built into Emacs already provides this. Though it supports customizing far more things, so it might be overwhelming. Maybe a new user customization group…
catern on HN
Prelude
From 1 comment
I discovered this project recently via some random HN post, and I've been contemplating using it to start over with my very chaotic Emacs configuration.…
macintux on HN
Doom Emacs and Spacemacs
From 2 comments
This is really cool. I'd recommend it for people who are into customization but want a solid foundation to start. For people who are looking for a more batteries included…
Kaze404 on HNUsed to maintain my emacs.d in github. These days, I just use spacemacs because I'm getting lazy.
jcadam on HN
Rational Emacs
From 1 comment
Cool tool! Would be interesting to integrate it straight to Emacs itself. But I think it is cool to be able to copy and paste it to one's own init.el…
jasau on HN