Muse
Productivity
thinking workspace
SHOW HN2022
How HN took it
12 positive, 26 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 29 critical, out of 71 comments about the project. Thread score -0.15.
Pricing: 4 for, 16 againstIdea: 5 for, 4 againstDesign: 2 for, 4 againstExecution: 1 for, 1 againstDocs: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Good design and polish appreciated by users
From 1 comment
Thanks Dan! Hope the Mac app is a good addition to your workflows as well.
adamwiggins on HN
Local-first sync and offline use praised as a selling point
From 1 comment
Objections
Subscription pricing is resisted by some users
From 2 comments
Exciting to see innovation in the note-taking and brainstorming space. Too bad I've decided that the subscription model has got to go, so I'm not interested in using the 'free'…
hatware on HNEnlighten us! How are people that don't want to pay for software "their best customers"? GoodNotes is great, hope they can make the one-off payment model sustainable. But the…
adamwiggins on HN
iPad and iPhone apps are limited, Mac app alone is limited
From 2 comments
Thanks for the review. Agree with most of your points here, briefly: iPhone app is just capture right now, intended for "I just had this thought that I need to muse on later." We…
adamwiggins on HNMuch appreciated. Sharing the journey is a big part of what has made this project fulfilling. As another commenter pointing out, the Mac app alone is somewhat limited without the…
adamwiggins on HN
Apple lock-in and tablet hardware dependence
From 2 comments
Very cool website, I can appreciate the effort that went into describing the features. I've been using Markdown-based tools for thought like Logseq and ObsidianMD, but have run…
rchaud on HNI skimmed the article, but what makes Android not sufficient to interact with Muse? I haven’t tried Muse, but I’ve thought plenty about building a local-first notebook app for…
dgreensp on HN
Requests
Free or cheaper alternatives
From 1 comment
Any free alternatives?
sydthrowaway on HN
Self-hosted sync service
From 1 comment
Evernote is a good example of software that I think had a lot of promise but has decayed in quality and performance over time. No self-hosted sync service at the moment. At the…
adamwiggins on HN
Better inking and smoothing
From 2 comments
I'm a big believer in tools that make us feel good about our work. Pretty handwriting as an output is in that category. You'd be surprised how much engineering goes into point…
adamwiggins on HNChanging while you write sounds surprising. All ink engines have some amount of retroactive smoothing going on, but typically (and this is the same for Muse) it should only be…
adamwiggins on HN
Questions
Whether data can be kept in version control or exported
From 1 comment
It's freemium rather than a trial, so you can use it for free for as long as you want. (Assuming I'm understanding your request there.) It does export a Muse bundle which is a…
adamwiggins on HN
Whether the app keeps working if the company shuts down
From 2 comments
If Muse disappears tomorrow. Servers shut down and all. Would access to notes still work? I am not actually in fear of something happening that suddenly. I defended the general…
skinnymuch on HNIn that case you'd still have full access to your documents. In keeping with local-first values the complete and canonical dataset resides on your devices (Macs/iPads). Sync…
adamwiggins on HN
Alternatives named
GoodNotes
From 1 comment
GoodNotes is great! More of a digital sketchbook (and better than Muse if you're focused purely on the inking/sketching part of things). On paying for software, here's some…
adamwiggins on HN
Obsidian
From 2 comments
Yeah, truly an unsolved problem. Obsidian seems to have found a good path--free for the core product, $10/mo (standard price for prosumer apps) for sync. But we felt like sync is…
adamwiggins on HNObsidian is great, and they are similarly priced to us ($10/mo for sync). We felt that local-first sync is a core feature of the product, and to exclude free users from that…
adamwiggins on HN
Kinopio
From 1 comment
Best bet here is web apps like https://kinopio.club/
adamwiggins on HN
OneNote
From 1 comment
Thanks for the review. Agree with most of your points here, briefly: iPhone app is just capture right now, intended for "I just had this thought that I need to muse on later." We…
adamwiggins on HN