bramses highly opinionated vault 2023
Productivity
note-taking vault
SHOW HN2022
Legend
bramses highly opinionated vault 2023
A highly opinionated, fully functional Obsidian vault
github.comHow HN took it
14 positive, 7 neutral or asking, 1 mixed, 9 critical, out of 31 comments about the project. Thread score +0.22.
Idea: 11 for, 7 againstDesign: 0 for, 1 againstExecution: 0 for, 1 againstDocs: 1 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Good example of how others use Obsidian; inspiring to see setups
From 4 comments
This is wild. I use Obsidian.. as a bunch of folders with text notes. The simplicity of the system is what works for me. But awesome to see somebody take the exact opposite…
Mizza on HNI really like seeing how others use Obsidian. As an Obsidian user and a (neo)vim user, I think there's a lot of overlap in why you should invest just-enough-time to make it work…
xcambar on HNGreat addition! Like others, I find it helpful to review how smart people are using Obsidian and related tools to create a second brain. I know it’s popular to critique these…
MrOrelliOReilly on HNThis is brilliant. Thanks for this, I'm going to be looking around to see what I can steal and improve mine. I have crashed Obsidian so many times when I tried to load up…
Brajeshwar on HN
Thought garden and capture ideas appreciated
From 2 comments
life well lived is a series of personal obsessions shared without expectation of an audience. well done. may an audience manifest around your knowledge of knowledge.
un1crom on HNOnly did a cursory read and I love it already. I tried sharing my own thoughts a while back but it was a first pass kind of post, this is much more complete. I'll be digging into…
adham-omran on HN
Objections
Second brain systems encourage over-configuring instead of getting work done
From 4 comments
Hypothesis: people who use these “second brain” knowledge systems spend more time writing about using them, then actually using them. Disclaimer: I use obsidian myself
dumbmrblah on HNAnyone organized enough to leverage such a system doesn’t need it!
Spooky23 on HNPeople should start using these apps as simple note-taking apps and extend/adapt them based on their needs, rather than diving head-first into these complicated methods/systems…
stranger555 on HNI think there is an ultimate unproductive productivity local minima there somewhere. I suspect if someone kept a knowledge base of productivity hacks it would tend towards…
nl on HN
Strong ngmi energy in this kind of obsession
From 1 comment
I have to say that there is a strong ngmi energy in this kind of obsession.
oxff on HN
Zettelkasten-style capture friction may stop users from capturing notes
From 1 comment
This is indeed highly opinionated, but one choice in particular may block half the potential userbase — stopping to think on capture: Zettelkasten "Unique Note Creator" - Is this…
Terretta on HN
Requests
Ability to tag whole blocks in Obsidian
From 1 comment
I try hard to take notes, but usually end up with a line or two. Maybe this is me, maybe the noise/information ratio of the meetings I am in - I do not know. I use and like…
BrandoElFollito on HN
Ask whether Obsidian is open source
From 1 comment
Obsidian is still closed source, right? I thought they were talking about open sourcing it at some point.
choward on HN
Feedback and links between published gardens (ActivityPub)
From 1 comment
>Visitors can meander around your thought garden [1], stopping to marvel at the hydrangeas, or beelining straight for the mini pagoda and water feature in the corner. What good…
s3000 on HN
Questions
How long have you been working with this setup?
From 1 comment
Thanks for sharing! How long have you been working with it? My biggest issue these days is that many tutorials or guides seem to be written at a point where the setup is still…
pflenker on HN
How to make default new-note location a global setting
From 1 comment
Thank you, works great! Any idea how I can make this the default setting, instead of needing to set it for each vault? Looks like I am not the only one who would like that:…
auggierose on HN
Alternatives named
Logseq
From 1 comment
i used to try to create obsidian workflows, but i found them very challenging to keep up. i used to think i wanted configuration for my note taking so I could capture all the…
breadchris on HN
Emacs with org-mode
From 2 comments
I get more done in Emacs and org-mode, at this point.
deafpolygon on HNThis is the same advice any greybeard gives newcomers to Emacs. Just start small.
deafpolygon on HN
Plain markdown with vim and scripts
From 1 comment
I disagree in terms of my own actual usage, after the initial excitement, but that is a real danger. That said, the most beneficial usage of my notes system has been the flat…
thenoblesunfish on HN
Notion
From 1 comment
At one point I tried creating what is Notion/Obsidian style system in 2013. I called it "living documents". here's one of the last surviving screenshots of living documents…
samsquire on HN