Restaurants in Peace
Consumer and social
closed restaurant memorial
SHOW HN2023
How HN took it
7 positive, 18 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 5 critical, out of 30 comments about the project. Thread score +0.06.
Execution: 2 for, 3 againstIdea: 2 for, 2 againstDesign: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Nostalgic, charming early-internet aesthetic with no trackers
From 2 comments
It's not just early 2000s aesthetics (I wouldn't know specifically about funeral homes, I didn't visit those pages then, nor do I now, it's the one line of business when I still…
fipar on HNCool website. Reminds me a lot of the early golden years of the internet
89vision on HN
Good idea that resonates with users' memories
From 2 comments
I knew other people felt the same way! There was this coffee shop I always hanged out, which recently "permanently closed" as the owner died RIP. It is really hard to explain…
log101 on HNReally good idea It would be nice if people could add restaurants, I guess you are worried that that would require too much moderation?
ajb on HN
Objections
Can't add new restaurants yet; submissions only by email
From 3 comments
How can you add a new place? If you want to avoid spam you could maybe ask for a Yelp link or something which you could scrape. There's plenty of really good restaurants which…
owenversteeg on HNDidn't see a way to add new ones... RIP Snacky. Oh how I loved my weekly pilgrimage to you. The spice in the air, the steam rising off the Bibim Bop, and the warm glow of anime…
syllablehq on HNReally good idea It would be nice if people could add restaurants, I guess you are worried that that would require too much moderation?
ajb on HN
City grouping is wrong; nearby cities mixed up
From 2 comments
I'm confused by the cities. Most of the restaurants under San Jose weren't in San Jose. And many of those were in San Francisco. But there's a San Francisco section.
pottertheotter on HNSorry, you're right! My geo math is a bit wrong, especially for cities that are nearby i.e. SF and San Jose (vs New York) I'll definitely investigate.
gregsadetsky on HN
Chain restaurants don't warrant remembrances
From 1 comment
When a restaurant closes that is functionally identical to every other franchisee, like an Applebees, Olive Garden, Burger King, etc., it doesn't need a remembrance because you…
progne on HN
Requests
Add a form to submit restaurants
From 3 comments
How can you add a new place? If you want to avoid spam you could maybe ask for a Yelp link or something which you could scrape. There's plenty of really good restaurants which…
owenversteeg on HNReally good idea It would be nice if people could add restaurants, I guess you are worried that that would require too much moderation?
ajb on HNinfo@restaurants.rip to add a new place right now, but I’ll definitely add a “submit” form today, thank you! I’m also in NYC, so I’d love to hear what you find.
gregsadetsky on HN
Add more cities such as Toronto and Montreal
From 2 comments
Too bad they don't have Toronto listed. There was a place called Il Gato Nero on College St that had been in a couple locations in the area for about 50 years. The family has a…
motohagiography on HNAwesome stories and writing that gave me intense second-hand nostalgia if that makes sense. I'm always pleasantly surprised to read about places I'm familiar with on HN. Thank…
EForEndeavour on HN
Add a list of latest remembrances
From 1 comment
I would love to see one where somebody has added a remembrance, but all the restaurants I click on are empty.
onionisafruit on HN
Show a map
From 1 comment
Any chance to add a map? I ate a great pasta in NYC when visiting with my girlfriend (2018=. Two years later (January 2020) I went to the same place with my dad and he liked it…
101008 on HN
Questions
How did they get restaurant data?
From 1 comment
How were they able to get this data? I’ve had lots of similar idea bur no idea on how I can get all data on restaurants in my city.
Alifatisk on HN
Can closed restaurants be mapped in OpenStreetMap?
From 2 comments
OpenStreetMap is for currently existing features (or currently existing remains, ruins can be mapped). So if for example sign remains, it can be mapped. But once fully gone: it…
matkoniecz on HNThat’s really interesting to learn, thanks. If it were up to me, I’d recommend keeping it with a flag that notes it as closed, rather than deleting it. (Just as you can mark a…
gregsadetsky on HN
Alternatives named
OpenStreetMap lifecycle tags and Open Historical Map
From 3 comments
> If it were up to me, I’d recommend keeping it with a flag that notes it as closed, rather than deleting it. OpenStreetMap has you covered with a so-called lifecycle prefix:…
habi on HNAs long as there are traces - it can be kept `disused:amenity=restaurant` rather than `amenity=restaurant` etc. But once fully gone it should be removed - this way OSM data can…
matkoniecz on HNOpenStreetMap is for currently existing features (or currently existing remains, ruins can be mapped). So if for example sign remains, it can be mapped. But once fully gone: it…
matkoniecz on HN
Yelp preserves closed restaurants
From 1 comment
It would be cool to have a feature like that, similar to how you could see previous years in Street View. Closed restaurants are preserved on Yelp, maybe there might be a way to…
Bluecobra on HN
Killed by Google
From 1 comment
Reminds me of https://killedbygoogle.com/ Makes me wonder. Is there a market for something like Upvoty (to gauge interested) + Kickstarter (to get commitment) for dead projects?…
pirsquare on HN