Rank a Day
Productivity
daily ranking game
SHOW HN2024
How HN took it
3 positive, 10 neutral or asking, 1 mixed, 12 critical, out of 26 comments about the project. Thread score -0.24.
Idea: 3 for, 6 againstDesign: 0 for, 6 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Fun and a good conversation starter
From 3 comments
This is fun. A couple of things: It's a bit confusing because I wasn't ranking anything, I was voting for things. I thought I was going to rank the three things I selected, for…
derbOac on HNI really like the general idea. I’m constantly doing this solo or with friends so good to see what others think. The long lists are a difficult UX, not sure how you completely…
streamfunk191 on HNOh, I like this!
matthewfelgate on HN
Pick-two comparisons would be more fun than long lists
From 2 comments
I was about to say the same thing. A trillion options is just unmanageable. One (other) solution is to create a tiny algorithm that lets the user choose the best one compared to…
thatwasunusual on HN> simple, fun task every day Honestly, comparing two options is much more fun than scrolling through a massive list and trying to figure out what your favourite item is
floodle on HN
Objections
Long list is hard to scan and overwhelming
From 3 comments
I was just coming here to ask if it could be alphabetical because the list is so long I can't find anything :) Maybe do Z-A instead? There's also so many fruits I've never heard…
mysterydip on HNThere's a lot of possible choices presented to the user, some of them totally out there like 'Ximenia'. Maybe there should be fewer choices, or can group them by what the author…
sys13 on HNI really like the general idea. I’m constantly doing this solo or with friends so good to see what others think. The long lists are a difficult UX, not sure how you completely…
streamfunk191 on HN
Alphabetical and early-position bias in results
From 3 comments
I noticed that Apple and Banana rank in the top two. While clearly they are very familiar fruit to your audience, they are also near the beginning of the alphabet. I wonder if…
martyvis on HNTry to shuffle the order of options to avoid bias (you can see apple and banana at top, both also in the beginning of the alphabet)
jiwidi on HNA to Z but reversed 50% of the time is the way to go to avoid bias while still being sorted one way or another
sebstefan on HN
Choosing only 3 items feels too limiting
From 1 comment
This is fun. A couple of things: It's a bit confusing because I wasn't ranking anything, I was voting for things. I thought I was going to rank the three things I selected, for…
derbOac on HN
Ranking unfamiliar items assumes knowledge people lack
From 2 comments
The problem is it assumes perfect knowledge of all the options. People should be able to remove the influence of their ranking for fruits they are not familiar with.
Chris2048 on HNFunny. The question asks "what is the best fruit?" - but the answers only show you what the most widely available fruits are. Anything that's lesser known or more expensive to…
hooby on HN
Requests
Use ELO or pairwise comparisons instead of a long list
From 2 comments
Would probably be better to show X and Y and let people select which is better (or skip), and compute an ELO score. A list with hundreds of items isn't great
stabbles on HNI was about to say the same thing. A trillion options is just unmanageable. One (other) solution is to create a tiny algorithm that lets the user choose the best one compared to…
thatwasunusual on HN
Allow user-submitted categories
From 1 comment
It might be fun if you allowed people to submit reasons or categories that make their choice the best. Today is "best fruit". What if I could submit the subcategory "best as a…
thaumasiotes on HN
Allow more than 3 picks or full ranking
From 1 comment
This is fun. A couple of things: It's a bit confusing because I wasn't ranking anything, I was voting for things. I thought I was going to rank the three things I selected, for…
derbOac on HN
Shuffle or randomize option order
From 2 comments
Try to shuffle the order of options to avoid bias (you can see apple and banana at top, both also in the beginning of the alphabet)
jiwidi on HNI changed it so they are ordered randomly now. Let see if that makes a difference. Having them in alphabetical does make it easier to find what you want but there is a search.…
pattle on HN
Questions
How are new daily topics added and what if none are queued?
From 1 comment
I'm interested what are the logistics of adding new topics for such "random thing every day" sites. I would guess that you maybe have a queue with topics for the next few days…
jiffygist on HN
Why are certain fruits like olives or tomatoes excluded?
From 2 comments
This list of fruits includes avocados, but not olives - both are arguably fruits. There are more: https://www.treehugger.com/vegetables-are-actually-fruits-4857900
thih9 on HNSorry I did exclude those fruits which people typically mistake as vegetables like tomatoes. Otherwise the list would have been too long.
pattle on HN
Alternatives named
ELO-based pairwise voting tools
From 1 comment
Would probably be better to show X and Y and let people select which is better (or skip), and compute an ELO score. A list with hundreds of items isn't great
stabbles on HN