Podlite
Languages and libraries
markup language
SHOW HN2024
How HN took it
3 positive, 11 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 8 critical, out of 22 comments about the project. Thread score -0.19.
Idea: 1 for, 4 againstDesign: 1 for, 3 againstExecution: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Extensibility and Markdown support are appealing
From 2 comments
Podlite indeed looks promising, especially with its extensibility and support for Markdown. I agree that if a markup language gets too complex, using raw HTML might be more…
PixelEngineer on HNWow. This is so good. For reference: It is 4 times smaller than HTML. It is 29.5 times smaller than PDF. It has a really good structure and is more readable than Markdown…
randomguid on HN
Playground and examples are useful
From 2 comments
It took me a few clicks but here's an example Podlite document for anyone who likes to jump straight into examples:…
simonw on HNjust jump in the playground: https://pod6.in/
burrish on HN
Objections
Too complex or heavy compared to Markdown and HTML
From 4 comments
Ouch. IMHO the reason markdown became so popular is because how simple it is, how well the syntax generally stays out of the way of the content, and its almost entire lack of…
TrueDuality on HNI think you've lost the point of Markdown: it's readable as raw text. I was excited that this was an extension of markdown but now I that see it I react with horror: markdown is…
john2095 on HNReading through the source for the specifications was interesitng. There is a lot of good stuff here, but there is so much to learn but I dont see enough benefits to push me to…
ThinkBeat on HNI thought the same thing when I saw the example page. Its closer to html than markdown.
the_real_cher on HN
Little benefit over existing tools like LaTeX, Markdown, HTML
From 2 comments
Reading through the source for the specifications was interesitng. There is a lot of good stuff here, but there is so much to learn but I dont see enough benefits to push me to…
ThinkBeat on HNWhile I think this is worth exploring, at a certain point you end up doing so much that you could just write raw HTML, and then you'd have the advantage of being able to display…
bachmeier on HN
Requests
More concrete examples on the front page
From 2 comments
Please put concrete examples right at the top of the page you're publicizing!
k8si on HNWhat's the main advantage over AsciiDoc? Although it's already on your roadmap, but it definitely needs more complex examples. Fiddled around a bit with links to same-doc…
WA on HN
Two-way editable playground
From 1 comment
That playground is cool. I wonder if there are any 2-way playgrounds where the right side is also editable using a Word / Google Docs style interface (and the changes are…
jon_richards on HN
Questions
What is the advantage over AsciiDoc or Org-mode
From 3 comments
What's the main advantage over AsciiDoc? Although it's already on your roadmap, but it definitely needs more complex examples. Fiddled around a bit with links to same-doc…
WA on HNPlease, anytime you try to imitate parts of org-mode, consider org-mode, markup and abilities.
kkfx on HNDamian Conway… a name to conjure with. What are the advantages of the Podlite design?
dash2 on HN
Is there a single-pass parser and EBNF spec
From 1 comment
Looks nice, I have a couple of questions: Does this use a single pass for the parser? Is there an EBNF spec? What sort of diagrams does it support? Thanks
alexisread on HN
Alternatives named
Markdown
From 2 comments
Ouch. IMHO the reason markdown became so popular is because how simple it is, how well the syntax generally stays out of the way of the content, and its almost entire lack of…
TrueDuality on HNI'm still upset that Markdown ended up getting all the mindshare. AsciiDoc is so much nicer.
asystole on HN
AsciiDoc
From 2 comments
What's the main advantage over AsciiDoc? Although it's already on your roadmap, but it definitely needs more complex examples. Fiddled around a bit with links to same-doc…
WA on HNAsciiDoc is much nicer, but has the unfortunate flaw of having basically one implementation and it's in Ruby (the JS one is just transpiled, the Java one runs on JRuby, not sure…
everforward on HN
Org-mode
From 2 comments
Please, anytime you try to imitate parts of org-mode, consider org-mode, markup and abilities.
kkfx on HNI had all kinds of plans for my knowledge management for over a decade. Then I started using org-roam and now the activation energy to consider anything else is so high that I'm…
exe34 on HN
Perl POD
From 2 comments
Isn't it the way perl scripts write their documentation? I don't know what makes it good for personal knowledge systems from reading the introduction
chj on HNPerl's POD, yes. But you're right! The spec authors are Perl folx, and this is clearly derivative. What's kind of interesting is that POD stands for "Plain Old Documentation" and…
apgwoz on HN
djot
From 1 comment
Might not work for my use case then. djot is single-pass so dovetails better with forth-style languages. I do like the blocks and mistake marking though :)
alexisread on HN