splashbe.at
Creative
music visualisation
SHOW HN2012
How HN took it
1 positive, 4 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 2 critical, out of 11 comments about the project. Thread score -0.07.
Idea: 1 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Cool, neat idea and nice UI
From 3 comments
Cool idea. Would like to read more about some of these genres, but can't get to the link quick enough before it fades away!
davidbrent on HNnice. how to force it to show electronica? I keep refreshing and all it comes is indie-something and rock. I got techno once, but when clicked it it showed some christian rock,…
zalew on HNNot the most graphically efficient demo I've ever seen, but neat.
mistercow on HN
Objections
Random or broken behaviour; results unrelated to what's on screen
From 3 comments
Seems totally random or broken. Whatever is on screen is completely unrelated (IMHO) and clicking on one thing takes you to something random. What's it supposed to do?
davedx on HNI keep getting 'Wood' and 'Poland', as well as occasional articles on wrestlers. When it works, it works well, though.
tshadwell on HNnice. how to force it to show electronica? I keep refreshing and all it comes is indie-something and rock. I got techno once, but when clicked it it showed some christian rock,…
zalew on HN
Unclear usefulness; clicking genres gives a large grey blob
From 1 comment
How is this useful? It shows how genres are related but if I click on two genres, it's a large grey ball of relations which shows exactly nothing except there are huge…
donum on HN
Slow to add genres and no caching
From 2 comments
1. no cache?! what year is this?! 2010?! 2. keeps automatically refreshing/restarting the graph every time I switch the tabs in Chrome 19. 3. at my first refresh I think it…
icehero on HNTakes to long to add rap music and country music. Could you add a feature to specify the Genre you want to add?
joeblau on HN
Graph is graphically inefficient and restarts when switching tabs
From 2 comments
Not the most graphically efficient demo I've ever seen, but neat.
mistercow on HN1. no cache?! what year is this?! 2010?! 2. keeps automatically refreshing/restarting the graph every time I switch the tabs in Chrome 19. 3. at my first refresh I think it…
icehero on HN
Requests
Let users specify which genre to add
From 2 comments
Takes to long to add rap music and country music. Could you add a feature to specify the Genre you want to add?
joeblau on HNnice. how to force it to show electronica? I keep refreshing and all it comes is indie-something and rock. I got techno once, but when clicked it it showed some christian rock,…
zalew on HN
Make links readable before they fade away
From 1 comment
Cool idea. Would like to read more about some of these genres, but can't get to the link quick enough before it fades away!
davidbrent on HN
Questions
What is it supposed to do?
From 1 comment
Seems totally random or broken. Whatever is on screen is completely unrelated (IMHO) and clicking on one thing takes you to something random. What's it supposed to do?
davedx on HN
Are duplicated nodes meaningful or a bug?
From 1 comment
Can anyone tell if the duplicated nodes has any meaning at all? Or, is only a bug?
aeurielesn on HN