TruckPlease
Web and SaaS
moving marketplace
SHOW HN2014
How HN took it
10 positive, 19 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 10 critical, out of 41 comments about the project. Thread score +0.00.
Idea: 6 for, 3 againstDesign: 0 for, 2 againstPricing: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Good idea that solves a real problem
From 3 comments
Best Idea I have read about all year. Seriously... I love this.
davemel37 on HN"Find someone who gives a truck." would be a better tagline. Other than that, really cool idea.
rabino on HNOwning a truck can be a blessing and a curse. I was never the driver when car pooling with my friends, but I had tons of requests to help move things--usually at the…
my_username_is_ on HN
Estate sale and retail delivery use cases look promising
From 2 comments
As someone who likes to buy consigned furniture, or browse estate sales... but hates paying expensive moving fees...This is a prefect solution for me. Focus on estate sales and…
davemel37 on HNThink about all the retailers that sell oversized products. Pretty much any item that can't fit into a sedan is a prime target. Build a large list of items from appliances, to…
davemel37 on HN
Objections
Gig wording and call to action are confusing
From 2 comments
Cool idea, but two things that bothered me: 1) There's no easy way for users to browse. 2) The whole "gig" messaging and the entire call to action on the page is painfully…
ignostic on HNInteresting... I'm from the UK and wouldn't generally refer to a 'gig' as anything but musical. E.g. Fiverr 'gig's caused me a lot of misunderstanding the first time I browsed…
sarreph on HN
Trust, safety and insurance for drivers and cargo are unresolved
From 3 comments
I've thought about this on and off over the years as well but never had the motivation to try. Congratulations. In all seriousness, the one question I could never answer for…
noonespecial on HNThe challenges go both ways, a-la Uber 1) How do I know the driver isn't going to steal my stuff 2) How do I know I'm not transporting drugs As a market place ensuring safety is…
joewee on HNThey face it with the corporate veil, insurance, and a bunch of lawyers. My concern is, as an ordinary guy with a truck who just bid on a job to make a little extra cash over the…
noonespecial on HN
Regulatory and licensing exposure as a broker
From 3 comments
"local or national" You really need to deal with both state and federal consumer-oriented laws relating to moving, and bills of lading and the like. You should also learn about…
redtexture on HNJust wondering if you are going to handel licensing, bounding, and insurance. It appears you could possibly be banging up against 3PL regulations.
rootedbox on HNThats right you would be the 3PL and you would be dealing with 1PL(consignee) and 2PL(carrier). So likely dealing with 3PL regulation. You probably already have to worry about…
rootedbox on HN
Existing tools like Craigslist and U-Haul already cover needs
From 2 comments
Given the infrequency of moving, I'm not sure how you intend to displace Craigslist for this sort of thing, since that website is already a good one-stop shop for random…
anigbrowl on HNAgreed. I'm moved several times, including twice cross-country and once internationally. Finding a truck was the least of my problems. If I just need a truck for the day to move…
keypusher on HN
Requests
Show example gigs or drivers on the home page
From 2 comments
You need to put something up on the home page which shows some of the gigs in your area or perhaps some of the drivers? Tough to see what the product looks like without actually…
MIT_Hacker on HNHey - co-founder here :) Yeah that's a good idea, a few people have pointed this out as well. Definitely something we'll add soon.
heidar on HN
Add a browse function for gigs
From 2 comments
Cool idea, but two things that bothered me: 1) There's no easy way for users to browse. 2) The whole "gig" messaging and the entire call to action on the page is painfully…
ignostic on HNHey, thanks so much for your feedback! We're working on adding a way for users to browse existing gigs right now! We chose to go with "gig" for two reasons: - It's a less formal…
sasan on HN
Reviews and driver verification
From 2 comments
I've used craigslist 4-5 times in the last 8 years (I don't drive, and I move a lot) - and two things stand out for me from my use of them: #1 - I'm continually amazed at how…
ghshephard on HNDefinitely agree! We're working on adding user generated reviews right now and would love to eventually verify drivers with their license/insurance info. Appreciate your input!
sasan on HN
Questions
How will the business make money
From 2 comments
I met Sasan and Heidar at the hackathon where they first built TruckPlease. Neat concept that definitely solves a problem, and they're smart/friendly guys! Super curious what…
mrmch on HNAs a user it is more reassuring to me if I can identify the business model or the fees involved up front. The FAQ states that the drivers don't pay anything, and the customers…
chrisBob on HN
How will they handle drugs or theft in the cargo
From 2 comments
I've thought about this on and off over the years as well but never had the motivation to try. Congratulations. In all seriousness, the one question I could never answer for…
noonespecial on HNThe challenges go both ways, a-la Uber 1) How do I know the driver isn't going to steal my stuff 2) How do I know I'm not transporting drugs As a market place ensuring safety is…
joewee on HN
Alternatives named
uShip
From 2 comments
How do you think you compare with established players, like uShip?
chiph on HNThis is going to hurt a little, but these guys are 10 years ahead of you: http://www.uship.com
damoncali on HN
Unpakt
From 1 comment
Unpakt.com is pretty good for this, though they index only professional moving companies. You enter the general stuff you're going to move and they compare prices across a bunch…
andrelayer on HN
Craigslist
From 1 comment
Given the infrequency of moving, I'm not sure how you intend to displace Craigslist for this sort of thing, since that website is already a good one-stop shop for random…
anigbrowl on HN
Moveline
From 1 comment
There is moveline.com, which I think was in TechStars out here in NYC a few years back. Is this more for small jobs within a city? Like if I needed to pick up some furniture or…
mtalantikite on HN
AnyVan
From 1 comment
An alternative that I've used successfully in Europe in the past is anyvan.com
knocte on HN