Sonar
Web and SaaS
customer messaging platform
SHOW HN2015
How HN took it
7 positive, 13 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 14 critical, out of 34 comments about the project. Thread score -0.17.
Idea: 6 for, 6 againstExecution: 0 for, 3 againstDesign: 0 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Simple, low-friction SMS interaction with no logins
From 2 comments
I believe a lot of the value is the simplicity of SMS. No logins, save the number in your phone and just text them like you would your friend with a request...done! You're right…
MatthewB on HNI actually do like this concept. I've always found it cumbersome that online support is a live session where either one of you can get disconnected at any time, or that you might…
jimlei on HN
Useful for small businesses with personal client management
From 1 comment
It's really frustrating to me when a Show HN gets thrashed this way. Every developer puts love into what they build, and most of the people here are developers that hopefully…
primitivesuave on HN
Objections
Post seen as opportunistic advertising piggybacking on Magic's launch
From 3 comments
I really don't like this opportunistic BS. These guys yesterday struggled with their launch and you took that opportunity to tell the world how to build a better clone? Cheap…
pothibo on HNIt's nothing like you describe. They go to great length to say how they love Magic to turn around and tell the world how to do build a better clone. Did they write about the…
pothibo on HNThe fact that you acknowledge the opportunistic part of my comment proves my point. Yes, when you love something so damn much, you don't go out there and tell people how to build…
pothibo on HN
Long codes raise FCC and spam compliance concerns
From 2 comments
Is this using a long code or a short code? The examples seem to show a long code, which is basically a phone number. The FCC is in the process of cracking down on companies that…
comrade1 on HNWe use long codes. There's a distinct difference between marketing/spam and customer service/support. When a customer initiates the conversation via text, it is generally seen as…
MatthewB on HN
SMS is poor for complex multi-step orders
From 1 comment
Right. Ordering stuff over SMS isn't that great an idea. There's going to be a lot of back and forth - what size do you want, is it OK if your flight has a change of planes at…
Animats on HN
Requests
Plugins for Salesforce, WHMCS, or Zendesk
From 1 comment
To make this really interesting, have you thought about making plugins/addons for, say, SalesForce/WHMCS/ZenDesk? A plugin there could easily allow this thing to skyrocket.
joshmn on HN
Questions
How payment info is captured and tied to phone numbers
From 2 comments
Can you give some insight in how a business would capture unique payment info related to a phone # in Stripe? Is there a payment link sent to users?
dinisp on HNI don't know how they're doing payments exactly but if I had to guess they are recording a customer's credit card info to stripe and associate to a phone number somewhere. Since…
MatthewB on HN
Why use Sonar instead of Twilio
From 2 comments
why would someone choose sonar over twilio?
klochner on HNgreat question. the main reason to use Sonar over twilio is that you'd have to essentially build our platform to be able to offer service like Magic. You need to be able to…
MatthewB on HN
Alternatives named
Twilio
From 1 comment
why would someone choose sonar over twilio?
klochner on HN
Magic
From 1 comment
I think this completely misses the point. The "magic" part of Magic isn't that it's over text -- that's just an implementation detail. Rather, the value is that it navigates all…
RaphiePS on HN
Amazon and web ordering
From 1 comment
Right. Ordering stuff over SMS isn't that great an idea. There's going to be a lot of back and forth - what size do you want, is it OK if your flight has a change of planes at…
Animats on HN