Airborn
Productivity
online document editor
SHOW HN2017
How HN took it
23 positive, 34 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 46 critical, out of 107 comments about the project. Thread score -0.14.
Privacy: 4 for, 20 againstDesign: 9 for, 14 againstExecution: 1 for, 8 againstIdea: 4 for, 0 againstDocs: 1 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Interface available in Esperanto and RTL support
From 2 comments
Their interface is available in Esperanto. That's already a huge point for me.
seizeheures on HNIf you select an RTL interface language, the UI becomes RTL. And in Chrome, you can select RTL in the editor in the context menu. Are you looking for something similar to that in…
twiss on HN
Looks slick and nostalgic cloud-OS feel
From 2 comments
Looks really slick! You should consider adding word support. Support for office XML formats[1] are simple enough to hand-roll.…
gatmne on HNThis app is making me ride the nostalgia train (circa 2005?) when AJAX was hot shit and everyone was making cloud OS. It has all the same elements: * window manager * apps *…
didip on HN
Objections
Service Worker trust model means the server must still be trusted
From 2 comments
"We (the makers of Airborn OS) won't be able to read them even if we wanted to." I take such claims with a huge grain of salt on the web. YOU serve the Javascript. YOU can change…
EGreg on HNThe very premises that a hacker can't read my data is laughable. Unless I'm using a native app to do the decryption a hacker could gain access to my data as it leaves your server…
jimktrains2 on HN
Name and OS-style UI confusing or unclear
From 2 comments
This looks great! Minor nits: In what way is this an OS? Also in the US, Airborn (e.g. to be in the air) is spelled "Airborne" and it's difficult to type it without the trailing…
bengotow on HNWhy does it have OS in the name? Is it an operating system? (This is a question I cannot find a direct answer to on their site) Their site makes it incredibly difficult to…
ArchReaper on HN
Back button breaks in Firefox
From 2 comments
It breaks the back button (stuck in a reloading loop). That alone is enough to make me move on, regardless of the potential privacy benefits.
morganvachon on HNYeah, it does that in Firefox, sorry about that. It works in Chrome.
twiss on HN
Registration errors reported
From 2 comments
I can't register. Getting "there was an error" message.
jeremyt on HNCould you try again? It might be just the server erroring out under load. Also, only Chrome, Firefox and Safari are supported.
twiss on HN
Requests
Numbered headers and styles
From 1 comment
One killer feature I am looking for is numbered headers/styles. Something Google Docs still lacks and I need Word for.
waytogo on HN
Word (docx) support
From 2 comments
Looks really slick! You should consider adding word support. Support for office XML formats[1] are simple enough to hand-roll.…
gatmne on HNWhat extent of docx support is important, do you feel? Is just importing docx to html (the native format) sufficient, or should they stay as docx while editing? Should it be…
twiss on HN
Self-hosting option
From 2 comments
Can this be self-hosted?
rambojazz on HNI see there's source, but don't see instructions for deploying.
starkruzr on HN
Questions
Is it an operating system?
From 2 comments
This looks great! Minor nits: In what way is this an OS? Also in the US, Airborn (e.g. to be in the air) is spelled "Airborne" and it's difficult to type it without the trailing…
bengotow on HNWhy does it have OS in the name? Is it an operating system? (This is a question I cannot find a direct answer to on their site) Their site makes it incredibly difficult to…
ArchReaper on HN
How the Service Worker verification works
From 2 comments
To solve this, [...use Service Workers] to install some code which can't be changed without setting off a warning to you. How does that work? Isn't a service worker started by…
krz8 on HN> For example, that first visit which installs the service worker can already deliver bad code. Yes, but that is also the case when you install a desktop app. That's why Airborn…
twiss on HN
Alternatives named
Google Docs
From 2 comments
Why does it have OS in the name? Is it an operating system? (This is a question I cannot find a direct answer to on their site) Their site makes it incredibly difficult to…
ArchReaper on HNGood timing with Google incorrectly flagging some Docs as abusive? (https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/zmz3yw/why-is-my-google-doc-locked-terms-of-service-bug)
amenghra on HN
Nextcloud with OnlyOffice or Collabora
From 2 comments
I see. What are you missing in Collabora? There's also OnlyOffice for Nextcloud, which is quite a feature-complete editor, I think: https://api.onlyoffice.com/editors/owncloud
twiss on HNYeah. While possible, Airborn OS isn't really meant to deploy yourself. If you want that, you might be better off with nextCloud or similar. Airborn OS was built to have a…
twiss on HN