Stock Trading from Google Spreadsheet
Finance and crypto
stock trading
SHOW HN2018
Legend
Stock Trading from Google Spreadsheet
Stock Trading from Google Spreadsheet
news.ycombinator.com281points
84comments
#98of 2,155 in 2018
Top 5%of 2018 by points
How HN took it
CuriousMostly questions and neutral comments
0 positive, 6 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 4 critical, out of 12 comments about the project. Thread score -0.27.
Idea: 0 for, 3 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Spreadsheet-driven trading is a familiar, flexible approach
From 2 comments
I can see that. Traders in Wall Street are too practical to build something maintainable. Now G Sheet brings the same power but to software developers this time.
umitanuki on HNExcel also gives people the comfort that they can track what goes in and out and adjust easily. Giving up that control is hard.
sct202 on HN
Objections
Spreadsheet trading is error-prone and risky
From 3 comments
Trading driven from a spreadsheet brings back horrible memories of my earliest days on Wall Street. Excel was usually hacked in the most grotesque ways: tick data coming in,…
anonu on HNWhen I was a trader at Merrill Lynch (NYC, 2005) I traded these basket securities on a Swiss exchange through a Rube-Goldberg-like trading system employing two Excel…
hx2a on HNCool, but first thought was a sarcastic “What could possibly wrong?”
paulcnichols on HN
Google Sheets is not suited to placing trades
From 2 comments
Trading driven from a spreadsheet brings back horrible memories of my earliest days on Wall Street. Excel was usually hacked in the most grotesque ways: tick data coming in,…
anonu on HNSmart to have a SUBMIT button. POST requests with Google Sheets is generally a bad idea since you can't explicitly control when they're sent.
hackerews on HN
Requests
Access to historical market data
From 1 comment
Looks like the press release was only a few weeks ago. I wish they provided some way to access historical data, however. I struggle to find accessible and inexpensive histories.
hellofunk on HN
Support for non-US users
From 1 comment
I wish Alpaca worked for Canadians. There is Questtrade, but comparing the documentation, it isn't as nice to work with.
thedangler on HN
Questions
Is there a catch to Alpaca and how does it make money
From 2 comments
Is there a catch to Alpaca? How do they make money?
syntaxing on HNAlapaca's business model [0]: > Alpaca will start offering Premium Plan subscriptions, where premium users will have access to various perks, such as higher quality live data…
dmos62 on HN
Alternatives named
Interactive Brokers
From 1 comment
Have you looked at Interactive Brokers? They seem to support more complex order types than Alpaca, which can meaningfully impact returns of a automated trading strategy.
nycdatasci on HN
Degiro
From 1 comment
Try degiro?
throwaway123mmm on HN
Robinhood
From 1 comment
These guys have actually been advertising on the radio lately (in the Los Angeles area). ``` https://www.robinhood.com/ ``` They are claiming zero commissions on US based…
TheGrassyKnoll on HN
Quantopian
From 1 comment
Quantopian ? https://www.quantopian.com/
TheGrassyKnoll on HN