MMO Asteroids
Games
browser multiplayer game
SHOW HN2012
How HN took it
5 positive, 18 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 12 critical, out of 39 comments about the project. Thread score -0.21.
Execution: 1 for, 4 againstDesign: 0 for, 4 againstIdea: 1 for, 2 againstPerformance: 0 for, 1 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Fun to play and a good laugh
From 3 comments
Wow, this is amusing. Seems like there are a lot of cool things you could do with Firebase.
rdl on HNIt's fun. Congratulations!
facorreia on HNIt also seems that spawning happens only in the top left section of the canvas, which makes that area especially crowded. It's a bit too easy to get killed right after spawning;…
mbrubeck on HN
Firebase shows promise for apps like this
From 2 comments
Awesome! I've been using Firebase for a while now and this further proves that it has so much potential! Every day I see more and more apps being built on it.
felixchan on HNWow, this is amusing. Seems like there are a lot of cool things you could do with Firebase.
rdl on HN
Objections
Too many players on one screen makes it frustrating
From 2 comments
Very cool. Quick feedback: there are too many players on one screen. Getting immediately run into and killed repeatedly by random players careening around isn't a great user…
hornbaker on HNI'll agree it's multiplayer, but considering gameplay goes from "fun and challenging" to "frustrating" at around 10-15 players, I doubt its massive-ness. However, if the map…
trafficone on HN
Cheating and hacks easy, scoreboard and god mode exploited
From 3 comments
God mode: "Game.ship.collision = function() {}" Also "Game.lives = 1000;" and "Game.score = 1000; updateScore();" etc.
forza on HNThe scoreboard has been hacked already!!!! Also, I'm not sure if I was regrouped with players who weren't signed in but after logging in with Twitter I no longer saw any other…
molsongolden on HNYou don't need the debug console, though: the database seems to simply be a shared scratch space, so anyone can just manipulate anyone else's state using the JavaScript API.
saurik on HN
Does not fit smaller or common screen resolutions
From 2 comments
Please can you make it scale to for a 1024*768 resolution? Thanks. I found it great fun dog fighting with another when it's a bit quieter. Annoyances were someone hacking the…
milkmiruku on HN``` > Please can you make it scale to for a 1024*768 resolution? ``` Mmmm. Doesn't fit in my 1280x800 screen's viewport either, which is a very common size.
h2s on HN
Too much inertia, hard to control ship
From 1 comment
I would definitely lower the inertia, it's not very enjoyable when there's such little control over what your doing also there's a bit of lag but that's to be expected with the…
sodafountan on HN
Requests
Play with friends or start a game together
From 2 comments
This is very cool! What would push it over the top for me would be the ability to start a game of it with my friends...
colomon on HNIs there anyway to make sure you start with specific people? Awesome job on the game :)
joncalhoun on HN
Co-op mode against asteroids
From 1 comment
The current mode is impressive, although may I suggest a co-op mode where you don't shoot other players but rather actual asteroids? Might be less crazy/frustrating that way.
MartinCron on HN
Scrolling map instead of wrapping
From 1 comment
I'll agree it's multiplayer, but considering gameplay goes from "fun and challenging" to "frustrating" at around 10-15 players, I doubt its massive-ness. However, if the map…
trafficone on HN
Hide-able chat
From 1 comment
Please can you make it scale to for a 1024*768 resolution? Thanks. I found it great fun dog fighting with another when it's a bit quieter. Annoyances were someone hacking the…
milkmiruku on HN
Questions
Why is it called Asteroids when there are no asteroids
From 1 comment
The problem with calling this Asteroids is that there are no asteroids. :) This reminds me more of an old DOS shareware game called Spacewar…
jaredsohn on HN
Why does Asteroids.com redirect to this site
From 1 comment
How do you happen to own asteroids.com? There must be a good story! :)
cpeterso on HN
Alternatives named
Spacewar
From 2 comments
The problem with calling this Asteroids is that there are no asteroids. :) This reminds me more of an old DOS shareware game called Spacewar…
jaredsohn on HNUh... Spacewar was an old PDP-1 game. It predates DOS by a little bit. And the microprocessor. And DRAM. And raster displays (the output was two analog channels fed to a raw…
ajross on HN
Subspace / Continuum
From 3 comments
There was another one called Subspace (now Continuum) http://www.getcontinuum.com/. I loved the early days of that game. 1997-ish.
jhickner on HNCool job! I wish there some an MMO that's like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SubSpace_(video_game) Good times…
justjimmy on HN.... looking for http://getcontinuum.com? :)
crux_ on HN
Star Control 2 melee mode
From 1 comment
Only partially related, but there was a fantastic game called Star Control 2 once upon a time. The main single player game was a big long quest, but it also had a 'Melee' mode…
untog on HN
Zap from OpenTNL
From 1 comment
Brings back memories of Zap from torque network library. http://sourceforge.net/projects/opentnl/files/Zap/ This little sample game turned out to be tons of fun and is a great…
joeld42 on HN