Quip
Learning and science
fact checking
SHOW HN2012
How HN took it
0 positive, 0 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 5 critical, out of 9 comments about the project. Thread score -0.45.
Execution: 0 for, 4 againstDesign: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Annotated debate format with factcheck.org references is a good idea
From 3 comments
The factcheck.org references are neat, though I kind of wish there were more of them. Is this supposed to be crowdsourced? ---------- Scrolling the notes is a little difficult. I…
Dove on HNMakes sense. Maybe put the username and comment together? It scared me off and I forgot what I was going to reply to. I do love the idea of these annotated debates. I wish the…
Dove on HNOverall, I'm pretty unimpressed with the quality of the crowdsourced comments -- which shouldn't come as any surprise to someone who's spent time on the internet. I love the…
Dove on HN
Objections
Crowdsourced comments are low quality
From 2 comments
Overall, I'm pretty unimpressed with the quality of the crowdsourced comments -- which shouldn't come as any surprise to someone who's spent time on the internet. I love the…
Dove on HN``` Quip writes (26:45) Thanks for participating in this demo of Quip. Click the next video (part 2) to keep watching the debates. Sign up for the beta if you're interested in…
aeontech on HN
Scrolling and comment UI are hard to use
From 2 comments
The factcheck.org references are neat, though I kind of wish there were more of them. Is this supposed to be crowdsourced? ---------- Scrolling the notes is a little difficult. I…
Dove on HNThe scrolling works well. It's a little weird, though, that it takes the mousewheel scrolling when I'm mousing over the comments. It makes sense, now that I've used it, it was…
Dove on HN
Safari fails to save annotations with a storage quota error
From 1 comment
Doesn't work in Safari. Can't leave an annotation. QUOTA_EXCEEDED_ERR: DOM Exception 22: An attempt was made to add something to storage that exceeded the quota.
zackb on HN
Video widget is hard to use for finding content
From 2 comments
I like what you're doing. Here are my thoughts: The widget on the right side looks cool, but the UX overall doesn't make sense for me because I don't want to rewatch the debate…
pfraze on HNIn projects like these, I wish more of the front end design put more attention on the generated content. I would like to see the latest (or latest and most upvoted) annotations…
danso on HN
Requests
Show latest or most upvoted annotations and let users jump to video time
From 1 comment
In projects like these, I wish more of the front end design put more attention on the generated content. I would like to see the latest (or latest and most upvoted) annotations…
danso on HN
More factcheck.org references
From 2 comments
The factcheck.org references are neat, though I kind of wish there were more of them. Is this supposed to be crowdsourced? ---------- Scrolling the notes is a little difficult. I…
Dove on HNMakes sense. Maybe put the username and comment together? It scared me off and I forgot what I was going to reply to. I do love the idea of these annotated debates. I wish the…
Dove on HN
Pre-annotate the debate's second half
From 1 comment
Makes sense. Maybe put the username and comment together? It scared me off and I forgot what I was going to reply to. I do love the idea of these annotated debates. I wish the…
Dove on HN
Summary or blurb view of fact-checks
From 1 comment
I like what you're doing. Here are my thoughts: The widget on the right side looks cool, but the UX overall doesn't make sense for me because I don't want to rewatch the debate…
pfraze on HN
Questions
Is this supposed to be crowdsourced?
From 1 comment
The factcheck.org references are neat, though I kind of wish there were more of them. Is this supposed to be crowdsourced? ---------- Scrolling the notes is a little difficult. I…
Dove on HN