Draft
Productivity
design feedback
SHOW HN2013
70points
59comments
#360of 1,739 in 2013
Top 21%of 2013 by points
How HN took it
CuriousMostly questions and neutral comments
10 positive, 33 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 9 critical, out of 54 comments about the project. Thread score +0.01.
Design: 4 for, 1 againstIdea: 3 for, 1 againstPricing: 0 for, 4 againstExecution: 0 for, 3 againstDocs: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Landing page and interactive demo above the fold are clear and well designed
From 3 comments
I love the signup page on this site. The writing style of the app itself speaking to you is a great twist and kept me scrolling at least. I have to agree with others here that…
michaelmartin on HNI loved the way you guys presented the simplicity of the app above the fold itself! I agree that there are lots of players in the space and adding to the list given above,…
ankit042 on HNThe site looks great. Simple, to the point with an obvious call to action. I have one question about the pricing. You say "x projects" and the cost is monthly. Is that x projects…
alanbyrne on HN
Simple, useful product concept
From 2 comments
Enjoyed the landing page and the product looks very simple and useful. However, I was thrown off by the demo image used (a login page) and was confused where I could sign up for…
stevenkovar on HNI think the site looks great. Kudos for giving the actual use case of the app with showing instead of telling. I think its a great overview of what you offer. I am curious as to…
EGF on HN
Objections
Crowded market with many similar apps
From 2 comments
First of all, this looks very nice and I have nothing bad to say about this particular product at all. But I can't help but wonder why there are so many apps like this. Off the…
sgdesign on HNI loved the way you guys presented the simplicity of the app above the fold itself! I agree that there are lots of players in the space and adding to the list given above,…
ankit042 on HN
Pricing too high compared to alternatives
From 3 comments
pricing too high. max pricing should be about 15.00 a month but just have a limit of storage and force people to dump old stuff.
michaelbuddy on HNthe right product in this space is going to shake things up on price. everyone is trying to squeeze too much out of this concept. and that's why it hasn't gained near the…
michaelbuddy on HNWhen compared to InvisionApp, which is what I use currently for sharing mocks and annotations capability - they have more features and for the same/similar price. You won't beat…
justjimmy on HN
14-day trial too short for teams
From 2 comments
This may just be me, but 14 days seems kind of strict for the type of projects it is for and given the learning curve of all the parties involved like someone else mentioned. It…
mnicole on HNThanks for responding! I would think so. I mean, I'd want to use it throughout the entire iterative process, so that means I'm waiting at least a week for everyone's feedback,…
mnicole on HN
Learning curve for clients
From 1 comment
Good idea, but unfortunately that product is really hard to establish because of the learning curve it introduces to everyone involved. I find it to be highly effective for…
Vinnix on HN
Requests
Simplify or reduce pricing tiers
From 2 comments
I think the site looks great. Kudos for giving the actual use case of the app with showing instead of telling. I think its a great overview of what you offer. I am curious as to…
EGF on HNWhen compared to InvisionApp, which is what I use currently for sharing mocks and annotations capability - they have more features and for the same/similar price. You won't beat…
justjimmy on HN
Export of feedback and content
From 1 comment
Free is always nice, but sometimes free can mean not around very long, which is not so nice, especially if you have tons of data stored, talking of which, is there a way to…
tudorw on HN
Longer free trial
From 2 comments
This may just be me, but 14 days seems kind of strict for the type of projects it is for and given the learning curve of all the parties involved like someone else mentioned. It…
mnicole on HNThanks for responding! I would think so. I mean, I'd want to use it throughout the entire iterative process, so that means I'm waiting at least a week for everyone's feedback,…
mnicole on HN
Git or version control integration
From 1 comment
Looks really interesting. I’ll definitely consider using this. Seems great for collaboration. Idea: integrate something like this with a version control system like Git(hub)?
TorbjornLunde on HN
Questions
Why build another app in a crowded market
From 1 comment
First of all, this looks very nice and I have nothing bad to say about this particular product at all. But I can't help but wonder why there are so many apps like this. Off the…
sgdesign on HN
How project limits work per plan
From 1 comment
The site looks great. Simple, to the point with an obvious call to action. I have one question about the pricing. You say "x projects" and the cost is monthly. Is that x projects…
alanbyrne on HN
Alternatives named
InvisionApp
From 1 comment
When compared to InvisionApp, which is what I use currently for sharing mocks and annotations capability - they have more features and for the same/similar price. You won't beat…
justjimmy on HN
Notable, LayerVault, Shipment, Cage, Marqueed, Moqups, Flatsie
From 1 comment
First of all, this looks very nice and I have nothing bad to say about this particular product at all. But I can't help but wonder why there are so many apps like this. Off the…
sgdesign on HN
Mocku.ps
From 1 comment
There is also a pretty cool (and free) alternative: http://mocku.ps
eliaskg on HN
Clarify.io
From 1 comment
we use http://clarify.io pretty cool too (and free)
sspross on HN
Framebench, Easyproof, Proofhq, Pixelapse, Conceptshare
From 1 comment
I loved the way you guys presented the simplicity of the app above the fold itself! I agree that there are lots of players in the space and adding to the list given above,…
ankit042 on HN