Kiwichat
Consumer and social
local chat
SHOW HN2014
50points
41comments
#642of 2,272 in 2014
Top 29%of 2014 by points
How HN took it
MixedNo clear lean
4 positive, 12 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 17 critical, out of 35 comments about the project. Thread score -0.34.
Idea: 1 for, 13 againstExecution: 1 for, 2 againstDesign: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Clean, fast, polished sign-in and UI
From 3 comments
I feel like there is definitely something in this basic idea. Although I'm not sure that a rigid 1 mile boundary really makes a whole lot of sense. I'll explain: I feel like the…
MartinMcGirk on HNI like this idea, the UI is fast and nice to use. I built something similar. The idea was to be able to play multiplayer games with people nearby. My motivation was simply to…
fmstephe on HNVery nice. I did something similar to test out Meteor.js, but it's much less polished than yours. http://mapchat.meteor.com/
erokar on HN
Objections
One-mile radius too small; rooms are usually empty
From 4 comments
There is no way someone is using this app a mile around me! I think 1 mile is too small of a distance, I would make it 5 or 10 miles. Or do something based on location, if you…
__xtrimsky on HNI agree that the 1 mile is too rigid. There are only going to be about 3,000 people within a mile radius of me (~1K/sq mile) whereas in Manhattan you would expect around 210,000…
cpwright on HNLove the idea. Wish the radius was wider. There aren't any chats near me, and I'm in a densely populated area. Since you're taking people's location, be sure to include a…
normloman on HNI was hanging out in Oakland for 45 minutes and didn't see another person come by -- I was expecting the Bay Area would have the densest group of people trying this out.
eastbayjake on HN
Chat needs critical mass and near-instant feedback
From 2 comments
In it's current form this doesn't work because chat requires almost immediate feedback.
ebbflowgo on HNI wrote the exact same thing about 3 years ago, according to HN timestamps: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2102790 I also had an arbitrary chat radius, initially. After…
Skywing on HN
Very similar to existing apps like Popcorn
From 2 comments
Already been done, Messaging within a 1 mile radius https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/popcorn-messaging/id718416705?mt=8
maxdarapper on HNReminds me of Popcorn app. This looks like a very similar idea but for the web.
bernatfp on HN
Requests
Use a wider or adaptive radius, or nearest N users
From 3 comments
Tried it for me. No-one online now. Another idea: Chat-room with the nearest 100 people. Scales up and down.
rmc on HNI see one of these pop up every so often and always get disappointed when there is no one in my area. I wonder if this sort of thing might work better if it connected you with…
morganherlocker on HNThere is no way someone is using this app a mile around me! I think 1 mile is too small of a distance, I would make it 5 or 10 miles. Or do something based on location, if you…
__xtrimsky on HN
Private messaging between users
From 1 comment
Private message between users as an option? So if I wanna talk to Brian later, I can PM them. Combine chat with interesting people, with random chances of meeting new people.
rmc on HN
Questions
How is the chat engine built?
From 1 comment
Very well done. Any background on how this is built? E.g. chat engine etc?
pfalke on HN
Alternatives named
Popcorn messaging app
From 1 comment
Already been done, Messaging within a 1 mile radius https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/popcorn-messaging/id718416705?mt=8
maxdarapper on HN
Yik Yak
From 1 comment
I've been trying the somewhat similar Yik Yak (mobile app) for about two weeks. It had flood of college students home for the summer so I assume it's taken off at colleges.
ja27 on HN
Caramail
From 1 comment
15 years too late, Caramail was doing the same in france since 1997 (http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/CaraMail) This is the type of thing where people will show up, see that their…
pouzy on HN
Meetro
From 1 comment
I too feel that the market has spoken on this: see http://www.crunchbase.com/organization/meetro and many others that failed.
cft on HN