Flakes
Dev tools
front-end framework
SHOW HN2014
How HN took it
13 positive, 15 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 13 critical, out of 45 comments about the project. Thread score -0.01.
Design: 8 for, 3 againstIdea: 3 for, 5 againstExecution: 0 for, 3 againstDocs: 0 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Clean, sleek look that suits business apps
From 4 comments
I wish more things looked like this at work. There's apps that look like native apps, there's bootstrap apps, there's all the custom CSS floating around, there's whatever's new,…
snlacks on HNI think that it looks clean and like it'd be easy to look at all day than something that's flashy.
nnnnni on HNI'd called that "lean and clean" instead of "boring". And I wish that more user facing apps would look like that, not just internal ones. Maybe it's just me, but all these flashy…
kbart on HNWell done. I work in a large enterprise and have no design ability. Tired of banging bootstrap together and not quite getting the look you achieved with Flakes. Looking forward…
rfc791 on HN
Grid forms and search/filter design are well liked
From 3 comments
I really like gridforms for dense data-entry forms (http://kumailht.com/gridforms/).
josekpaul on HNThis is really cool and a nice start. One big thing we are dealing with in our internal app are responsive tables. We display some data in tables, but it almost always looks like…
toddsiegel on HNI think it looks sharp. But the monotonality, or lack of contrast within the layouts blends elements together, so I would find it difficult to read and interact with for an…
b2themax on HN
Useful component set that covers most use cases
From 1 comment
This is a pleasant change. My goto framework for internal apps is Bootstrap (no surprise there) although I actually end up using only a handful of elements. Flakes looks like a…
krat0sprakhar on HN
Objections
Unclear why to choose it over Bootstrap
From 4 comments
Is there any compelling reason to try this if I'm already comfortable with using Bootstrap for internal apps?
jchendy on HNThere's some nice visuals here but it's hard to see why I should choose to invest my time into learning this rather than something more standard like Bootstrap. And I don't…
pimlottc on HNThis looks great. I'd like to know: 1) how does this differ from bootstrap? 2) why a whole new framework, instead of extending bootstrap?
andyl on HNI prefer something more feature-rich, using a known framework like Bootstrap. There's a lot more features and examples built in to inexpensive templates for Admin interfaces like…
alongnion on HN
Boring, bland design conflicts with user-experience goals
From 3 comments
I'd like to understand more about the rationale that led you down the path of creating this. In my years in enterprise, user and market research has driven the push to create UIs…
rrrx3 on HNThe research shows that there should be a greater convergence because of the cognitive dissonance that occurs otherwise. It is an inarguable fact that people are using software…
rrrx3 on HN"Compelling" refers to aesthetics and feeling of reward when using the application - "This is an attractive application that makes me feel good when i use it", while "at home &…
rrrx3 on HN
Front-end architecture is regressive, relying on jQuery and server-side rendering
From 1 comment
Lots of nice work put into this, but I think some of the fundamental architectural assumptions are a little regressive. For instance, it looks like the boilerplate expects a lot…
languagehacker on HN
Bugs found in demo controls such as Next button and select all checkbox
From 2 comments
Went to this page: http://getflakes.com/preview/browsing-data.html The 'Next' button on the grid seems to be broken. No javascript error in console. Current stable Chrome, Windows.
rikkus on HNThe 'select all' checkbox on http://getflakes.com/preview/tables.html has no effect my Chrome.
doque on HN
Requests
Add admin components such as grids, cards and wizards
From 2 comments
Nicely done, but if you are really trying to be a framework for internal apps (vs a design framework like bootstrap) - I would focus on adding a couple of more admin-like…
ckluis on HNThis is really cool and a nice start. One big thing we are dealing with in our internal app are responsive tables. We display some data in tables, but it almost always looks like…
toddsiegel on HN
Add charting integration
From 2 comments
Not sure why Bootstrap bloat is a problem if it's just going to be an internal app. I'd rather go with a more familiar, and well known framework, and not have the overhead of…
hwgd on HNI think it's strange that they use Morris.js[1] for their graphs on the main pages, but don't mention it anywhere. [1]https://morrisjs.github.io/morris.js/
JelteF on HN
Support Bootstrap or Foundation as base styling
From 1 comment
Very nice work. Given the prevalence of Bootstrap and Foundation, it would probably help adoption if there were options with those as the base styling lib. I know there is a lot…
alanning on HN
Questions
How does it differ from Bootstrap
From 2 comments
This looks great. I'd like to know: 1) how does this differ from bootstrap? 2) why a whole new framework, instead of extending bootstrap?
andyl on HNIs there any compelling reason to try this if I'm already comfortable with using Bootstrap for internal apps?
jchendy on HN
What license is it under
From 1 comment
License? Scanned both the github and docs for any mention of it.
rMBP on HN
Alternatives named
Bootstrap
From 3 comments
Is there any compelling reason to try this if I'm already comfortable with using Bootstrap for internal apps?
jchendy on HNThis looks great. I'd like to know: 1) how does this differ from bootstrap? 2) why a whole new framework, instead of extending bootstrap?
andyl on HNNot sure why Bootstrap bloat is a problem if it's just going to be an internal app. I'd rather go with a more familiar, and well known framework, and not have the overhead of…
hwgd on HN
Foundation
From 1 comment
Very nice work. Given the prevalence of Bootstrap and Foundation, it would probably help adoption if there were options with those as the base styling lib. I know there is a lot…
alanning on HN
Semantic UI
From 1 comment
Nicely done, but if you are really trying to be a framework for internal apps (vs a design framework like bootstrap) - I would focus on adding a couple of more admin-like…
ckluis on HN
OpenUI5
From 1 comment
What about OpenUI5 for business apps: https://openui5.hana.ondemand.com/#content/Controls/index.html From my initial tests, it's very clean MVC (a bit verbose). Also the deploy…
ivan_ah on HN
SmartAdmin
From 1 comment
I prefer something more feature-rich, using a known framework like Bootstrap. There's a lot more features and examples built in to inexpensive templates for Admin interfaces like…
alongnion on HN