Spot the Drowning Child

Learning and science

water safety training game

SHOW HN2015

1,215points
378comments
#1of 2,565 in 2015
Top 1%of 2015 by points

How HN took it

CuriousMostly questions and neutral comments

18 positive, 47 neutral or asking, 5 mixed, 17 critical, out of 87 comments about the project. Thread score +0.07.

Idea: 9 for, 3 againstDesign: 3 for, 7 againstExecution: 1 for, 6 against

The thread, comment by comment

Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.

positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker

What HN said

What people liked

  • Good educational training tool for recognizing drowning

    From 4 comments
    • A few weeks ago I was sitting 6 feet from the edge of a community pool while many parents and their children were swimming. Out of nowhere one of the lifeguards on the opposite…
      rdoherty on HN
    • The biggest eye-opener to me was the "Instinctive Drowning Response" article shared a few days ago. So few people notice someone drowning, even when only feet away. I feel it's a…
      Nadya on HN
    • Brilliantly done.
      ef4 on HN
    • This is great idea but confusing. I missed the drowning event and tried to replay, but the controls are hidden. Clicking on the logo I got to an identical looking, but different…
      afandian on HN

Objections

  • Timing is confusing; the drowning kid is only clear a few seconds before rescue

    From 3 comments
    • I found this a bit confusing. I thought it was one of those things where the drowning kid doesn't look like he was drowning. But instead, no one is generally drowning in the…
      smackfu on HN
    • I clicked on the drowning boy about 6 seconds after he slipped out from his tube, and the site's response was "Just splashing around, keep looking." Then I tried it a few more…
      corndoge on HN
    • Just me, or is this vid not a great example?...the kid is pretty clearly struggling.
      totalrobe on HN
  • Interface lacks feedback and video controls

    From 4 comments
    • This didn't seem to do anything for me. I clicked on the kid I thought was in trouble and the video just paused. When I continued the video, I saw that I had in fact chosen the…
      jacalata on HN
    • Good idea. Looking at it first though i was a little confused. The video plays immediately, so i didn't realize it was interactive because i had no time to read the text and no…
      Mithaldu on HN
    • This is great idea but confusing. I missed the drowning event and tried to replay, but the controls are hidden. Clicking on the logo I got to an identical looking, but different…
      afandian on HN
    • I clicked on the kid as soon as he kicked off from the wall, as he was already panicking while trying to hold on to the rope and it didn't give me points. The next one in the…
      X-Istence on HN

Requests

  • Clearer scoring and replay controls

    From 2 comments
    • The biggest eye-opener to me was the "Instinctive Drowning Response" article shared a few days ago. So few people notice someone drowning, even when only feet away. I feel it's a…
      Nadya on HN
    • This is great idea but confusing. I missed the drowning event and tried to replay, but the controls are hidden. Clicking on the logo I got to an identical looking, but different…
      afandian on HN
  • Automated drowning detection with cameras and machine learning

    From 3 comments
    • Fellow HN readers: We're a smart bunch of hackers. Why don't we have a startup working on a technology that could recognize and alert lifeguards when swimmers are in danger? I…
      northben on HN
    • I noticed this is likely a video from a "security" camera. Would it be possible to apply Motion Detection Algorithms software to realtime video for the purpose of alerting…
      GBond on HN
    • Any computer vision / machine learning experts want to weigh in on the difficulty involved in writing an algorithm to visually detect drowning?
      ZitchDog on HN

Questions

  • How does drowning differ from a weak swimmer treading water?

    From 1 comment
    • I watched a few of the rescues, and they were all of kids falling out of their floaties and seemingly unable to swim at all. What does it look like when an able swimmer…
      bsznjyewgd on HN

Alternatives named

  • Pool safety camera systems

    From 1 comment
    • Lifeguards and programmers have something in common – though it looks like both spend their day sitting and staring at a rectangle, there's a lot going on mentally, and the risk…
      jkoschei on HN

Category, keywords, summaries and labels on this page were made by AI (Thread Reader v2) and not checked by hand. Each point links to the comments it came from.

Add a badge to your READMEShown on HackerShow
[![Shown on HackerShow](https://hackershow.org/badge.svg)](https://hackershow.org/show/9962185)