Jackfruit
Productivity
team video collaboration
SHOW HN2019
How HN took it
5 positive, 5 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 10 critical, out of 22 comments about the project. Thread score -0.17.
Idea: 4 for, 5 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 2 againstExecution: 1 for, 1 againstPerformance: 0 for, 1 againstDesign: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Good for frictionless standups
From 1 comment
I would totally play into “frictionless standups” and specialize the hell out of experience. For one, I think it avoids a lot of “creep factor” that other commenters keyed into.…
awinder on HN
Slick implementation, opt-in rooms
From 1 comment
Pretty slick implementation. Was also wary about the always on video rooms but it seems they’re opt in for the most part.
gxespino on HN
Virtual water cooler idea appeals
From 1 comment
I like this idea. Discord has it for audio. Our fully-remote company pretty much uses zoom in a somewhat similar way. "Always-on" doesn't have to mean everyone is always in the…
ilikehurdles on HN
Objections
Feels like surveillance or micromanagement risk
From 3 comments
Having done remote work I completely get what you’re trying to achieve. It’s not the tool which is causing a cautious(?) reaction but knowing how unscrupulous micro-managers…
mikece on HNPretty cool, but terrifying. I would be in constant stress and probably resign the day after if I was required to join an alway-on call. I work remotely.
ecmascript on HNGreat job on building something but man I’d hate it if employers actually demanded always on video, even for calls. Slack is pretty intrusive as is.
isatty on HN
Always-on video is creepy and stressful
From 3 comments
This feels like a nightmare to me. If I am thinking and in concentration - all external stimulation needs to be shut off.
xfitm3 on HNAlways-on video staring at people's faces is weird in the best circumstances. It's a bizarre view to have passively, rather than during active conversation.
shantly on HNI think it’s creepy.
t34543 on HN
Privacy risk of video showing home environment
From 1 comment
We used an always-on-video solution (the now dead Sqwiggle) in a past startup. It all went relatively well until one day, the wife of one of your coworkers, walked naked in the…
juandazapata on HN
Resource use of another web app
From 1 comment
I find I have to keep these sorts of always-on things (some kind of text chat aside) on a dedicated device (iPad, another laptop) or they drive me nuts. The resource use of Yet…
shantly on HN
Requests
Hide everything except face in video
From 1 comment
minor typo: "your" vs "our" coworkers. I guess it would be handy to have some way of hiding everything except maybe the face. Would be annoying to have to dress up
fouc on HN
Fix screen sharing on Chrome OS
From 1 comment
On chrome os screen sharing button is disabled even though it's still chrome.
cyberpanther on HN
Questions
Will Slack build this itself?
From 1 comment
@drpancake -- aren't you nervous about Slack doing something just like this? They seem to own all the technology required.
cpr on HN
Alternatives named
Google Hangouts
From 1 comment
Our company is fully remote. We have an always-on Google Hangout that everyone is on all day. The key for this to work is that everyone has their mic + camera turned off except…
cj on HN
Discord voice channels
From 2 comments
Not to take away from the efforts of the developer but this basically turns Slack into Discord. Which I think would be interesting. I think always open audio channels are useful…
giancarlostoro on HNI like this idea. Discord has it for audio. Our fully-remote company pretty much uses zoom in a somewhat similar way. "Always-on" doesn't have to mean everyone is always in the…
ilikehurdles on HN
Sqwiggle
From 1 comment
We used an always-on-video solution (the now dead Sqwiggle) in a past startup. It all went relatively well until one day, the wife of one of your coworkers, walked naked in the…
juandazapata on HN
Focusmate
From 1 comment
That's a fantastic idea! there's something like focusmate.com to do something similar, 1 hour blocks of being on video with another person, both of you share your goals in the…
fouc on HN
Camfrog
From 1 comment
Go look at Camfrog. Make a web version that does what they do. You will have much better success.
lightedman on HN